Accidental Tech Podcast
Accidental Tech Podcast

121: Admitted No Wrongdoing

Our WWDC 2015 special, live in person from a hotel room in San Francisco: * The keynote presentation * Mac OS X 10.11 El Capitan * Natural-language search * Window management * iOS 9 * iPad enhancements: * Keyboard navigation gestures * Side-by-side apps * Will these revive iPad sales growth? * New

Featured Speakers

Marco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: A live WWDC recap covers first impressions of OS X El Capitan, iOS 9, Swift 2.0/open sourcing, Notes/News changes, watchOS 2, and Apple Music. The hosts praise Apple’s developer-focused features, privacy stance, and greater diversity on stage, but criticize Apple Music’s presentation as long and uninspiring. The episode also includes ad reads and a comedic toaster review.

Main Topics: WWDC keynote first impressions: The hosts emphasize that they were live in the room, reacting to crowd energy, pacing, and what Apple chose not to emphasize. They frame the discussion as first impressions rather than a complete technical breakdown. OS X El Capitan: They discuss the new naming, subtle UI changes, performance and under-the-hood improvements, window management, and Metal coming to the Mac. The release is seen as evolutionary rather than a huge visual overhaul. iOS 9 and iPad productivity: The conversation focuses on Spotlight/proactive features, on-device intelligence, improved natural language search, iPad multitasking, and keyboard/trackpad-style cursor control. They see Apple trying to make the iPad more viable as a work device. Swift 2.0 open source: The open sourcing of Swift and its standard library is greeted as a major developer confidence signal. The hosts debate what is actually open, and how much this could matter for server-side and cross-platform use. Notes and News apps: The new Notes app is praised as a richer, more capable cross-device note-taking tool, while News is viewed skeptically as an Apple attempt at an RSS/news aggregation platform that may repeat Newsstand’s problems. watchOS 2 and watch app capabilities: Third-party complications, time travel, and native watch apps are highlighted as major watch upgrades. The hosts are excited but cautious about battery drain, limits, and app behavior. Apple Music and presentation style: Apple Music is criticized as too long, unfocused, and not compelling enough during a developer conference. The hosts feel the music segment was a weak ending compared with the rest of the keynote.

Key Arguments: The keynote’s strongest material was the first three-quarters; the energy fell off during Apple Music. El Capitan is a smaller, refinement-focused release, but Apple avoided framing it as a defensive or apologetic update. Apple is building Google Now-like intelligence while keeping data on-device, which preserves privacy but may limit cross-device usefulness. Natural-language search and proactive suggestions are important because they make Apple’s interfaces more approachable than old query-syntax systems. Swift being open sourced makes the language feel more legitimate and lowers long-term developer risk, even if most Apple frameworks remain closed. The new Notes app is promising because it finally looks like a serious cross-platform note editor with rich formatting and syncing. Apple News may struggle if publishers cannot monetize or if users do not adopt it; Newsstand’s failure is a warning sign. watchOS 2’s biggest value is in better notifications and glanceable data, but poorly designed apps/complications could hurt battery life. Apple’s increased visibility of women presenters was celebrated as overdue and meaningful. Apple Music’s curation-first pitch may appeal to some users, but the hosts found the presentation bloated and not sufficiently differentiated.

Data Points: WWDC keynote duration: about seven hours long - The hosts joke that the keynote was extremely long and could only be covered partially. Apple ecosystem diversity on stage: 2 women presenters - They note it was striking and welcome to see two women presenting at the keynote. iPad Air 2 multitasking support: only the iPad Air 2 can run two apps side by side indefinitely - They discuss split-screen multitasking and device limitations. watch face sizes: 38 mm and 42 mm - Used when discussing complications and watchOS 2 interfaces. Apple Music family pricing: one payment for an entire family - Mentioned as a major structural improvement in the new music service. Automatic price: $100 normal / $80 with podcast code - Ad read for the OBD-II car dongle service. Squarespace starting price: $8 per month - Ad read for website building service. Squarespace annual plan bonus: free domain name - Mentioned as part of the annual subscription offer. Hamilton Beach toaster price: $30 - The toaster review identifies the model as low-cost but poor-performing. Apple watchOS native app communication: can read from shared container - The hosts discuss how watch apps communicate with the iPhone app and what happens when the phone is absent.

Pivotal Quotes: "If Tim Cook would have ended and instead of saying one more thing, said, Thanks, this will be a great week. You know, we'll see what you guys can do with this. Thanks a lot." — Marco: Summarizing how the keynote would have felt without the Apple Music finale. "I do not understand how. It has a three and a half star rating on Amazon." — John: During the toaster review, expressing disbelief that the hybrid toaster-oven/toaster product is rated well. "This is our corporate differentiator, this is what we believe as people that we don't want that thing, or that it's like that's what they have." — Marco: Discussing Apple’s on-device privacy strategy versus Google-style cloud intelligence.

Implications: Apple is pushing toward more contextual, on-device computing across Mac, iPhone, iPad, and Watch. If the new features work well, they could make Apple devices feel smarter without giving up privacy, while also pressuring developers to adapt to new platform constraints.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Accidental Tech Podcast

View all episodes from Accidental Tech Podcast