Accidental Tech Podcast
Accidental Tech Podcast

191: The Failure Mode of a Train

* Dealing with DNS trouble * Hover outage * DDoS * Follow-up: * Steve Troughton-Smith poll on iCloud files * Casey's headphones update * Motorola S305 * Plantronics Backbeat Fit * Kinivo BTH260 * LG Tone Pro HBS-750 * Aftershokz Trekz Titanium * Jaybird X2 * Greg Koenig on the ceramic iPhone *

Featured Speakers

Marco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode centers on four threads: a DNS outage that disrupted the live stream, follow-up on iCloud Desktop/Documents syncing and headphone options, a detailed debate over Apple’s handling of a developer account termination tied to app-review fraud, and a long technical discussion about Dropbox’s recent behavior and potential alternatives. The hosts also revisit Apple device materials and camera gear tradeoffs, especially mirrorless vs DSLR ergonomics and battery life.

Main Topics: DNS outage and live-stream recovery: The show opens with a practical tale of surviving a Hover DNS/DDoS outage by moving the stream to a new hostname and creating a quick virtual host on the server. Apple developer account termination and Dash controversy: A major segment examines the Bogdan Popescu/Dash account suspension, Apple’s fraud rationale, the public backlash, and whether Apple treated the situation fairly or prudently. Dropbox accessibility hack and trust concerns: The hosts critique Dropbox for forceful accessibility persistence and deeper system integration behavior, then explore what that means for trust and whether they could leave Dropbox. Alternatives to Dropbox for sync and collaboration: They compare Dropbox replacements such as Resilio, Seafile, Google Drive, and iCloud Drive, focusing on shared folders, mobile support, and the ability to quit/disable the service cleanly. Apple material rumors: glass, ceramic, carbon fiber, and aluminum: They discuss why ceramic is unlikely for iPhones at scale, what Apple’s long-term next material might be, and whether carbon fiber or plastic could eventually replace aluminum. Camera ecosystem and pro gear ergonomics: A lengthy post-show discussion covers Marco’s shift from Sony mirrorless back toward Canon DSLRs due to battery life, speed, lens availability, and overall shooting experience. Headphone and accessory recommendations: There is follow-up on Bluetooth headphone options, including behind-the-neck designs, bone-conduction headphones, and AirPods, plus the ergonomics of remote controls and battery life.

Key Arguments: The DNS problem showed how dependent services can be on external infrastructure, but also how quickly a host can recover by changing hostnames and virtual hosts. Apple likely had a legitimate basis to terminate the linked account because fraud activity and shared identity signals (same credit card/test devices) connected the accounts. At the same time, Apple’s reputation problem remains: developers still instinctively assume the company may be wrong or arbitrary in App Store enforcement. Dropbox’s accessibility behavior is seen as a trust issue, not just a technical nuisance, because it crosses a line from convenience into stealthy persistence. If Dropbox continues making questionable product decisions, users like Marco may gradually move critical workflows elsewhere, but the migration cost is high because Dropbox is deeply embedded in collaboration and personal workflows. Apple probably will not move to ceramic iPhones any time soon because the manufacturing ramp, tooling, and throughput requirements would be enormous and visible in supply-chain signals. Carbon fiber is the most plausible long-term successor material discussed, but it may appear first in lower-volume devices like laptops before phones. Battery life and handling speed matter more to some photographers than raw sensor quality; a pro DSLR can feel more usable than a newer mirrorless body if it is faster and more reliable in practice.

Data Points: Live-stream delay: 7–8 minutes - The tweet announcing the live show used a very short time interval because the DNS outage consumed the setup window. DNS outage duration: 5–6 hours - Hover’s DNS disruption affected the site for several hours before the workaround stabilized the stream. Twitter poll result: yes, happy: 30% - Poll about enabling desktop/documents iCloud sync on macOS Sierra. Twitter poll result: yes, regretted it: 4% - Same poll, indicating a small but non-zero group who disliked the feature. Twitter poll result: no: 29% - Same poll, showing many users avoided enabling the feature. Twitter poll result: hell no: 37% - Same poll, the largest response, suggesting widespread skepticism. Betterment assets under management: $5.5 billion+ - Ad read described Betterment as managing billions for customers. Betterment customers: 180,000+ - Ad read cited the company’s customer base. Pingdom outages detected per month: 13 million+ - Ad read on Pingdom’s monitoring scale. Pingdom outages detected per day: 400,000+ - Ad read converting monthly outages into daily volume. Apple iPhone production rate: ~1 million/day - Used to explain why adding a new manufacturing material like ceramic would be a massive undertaking. Dash call recording length: ~10 minutes - The developer posted a recorded phone call with Apple as part of the dispute. Dash/App Store linked-account signal: same credit card and test devices - Used as the basis for Apple treating the accounts as connected. Canon 5D Mark IV upgrade price delta: about $500 more - Marco noted the new camera body had increased in price relative to his expectations.

Pivotal Quotes: "Apple is a hardware company, and machined aluminum is their primary platform." — Marco: Used to argue that Apple’s manufacturing system makes a ceramic iPhone unlikely in the near term. "People, developers, still don't trust that we are going to do the right thing." — John: Summarizing the lingering App Store trust deficit exposed by the Dash/Apple dispute. "I just love pro cameras, and that the Sony, in some ways, isn't a Pro camera in the ways that I am considering here." — Marco: Explaining why he may switch back from mirrorless to DSLR despite the Sony’s technical strengths.

Implications: The episode suggests that trust in platform vendors remains fragile: Apple can improve developer confidence only through visible fairness, while Dropbox risks alienating power users with opaque behavior. Listeners are encouraged to monitor their infrastructure, question convenience that overrides consent, and weigh workflow lock-in carefully.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Accidental Tech Podcast

View all episodes from Accidental Tech Podcast