Accidental Tech Podcast
Accidental Tech Podcast

316: MacBook Hierarchy of Needs

* Follow-up: * Two-hand Springboard rearrangement * Ask Tog * Creative Selection by Ken Kocienda * Finding 32-bit apps * Corning is working on flexible glass * Star Trek IV: The Voyage Home * Thunderbolt 3 → USB4 * Microsoft's Xbox Game Pass * Apple vs. NVIDIA * System Integrity Protection * CU

Featured Speakers

Marco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode spans a rapid-fire mix of Apple ecosystem complaints and future-product speculation: Chrome’s awkward Mac behavior and update process, iOS/iPadOS drag-and-drop and Springboard frustrations, foldable glass and USB4/Thunderbolt’s future, Apple’s strained relationship with NVIDIA, the case for fewer configurable Macs, and a broader wishlist for next-gen MacBooks. The after-show also covers the Polestar 2 EV and what makes a compelling electric car beyond Tesla.

Main Topics: Chrome on Mac: security updates and macOS hostility: The hosts gripe about Chrome’s non-Mac-like behavior, battery drain, awkward update flow, and the confusion around emergency security updates, contrasting it with Safari’s reliability and DevTools advantages. iOS/iPadOS drag-and-drop and Springboard usability: A long discussion about the unreliability of rearranging icons on iOS, the multi-finger workaround, drag-and-drop delays, and the broader issue of touch interfaces that are inherently error-prone compared with more explicit desktop interactions. Apple hardware roadmap: configurable Macs, ARM, and laptop priorities: The hosts debate the future of Mac configurability, arguing that Apple can simplify CPU/RAM options on lower-end machines while still offering storage choices, but should fix the MacBook Pro keyboard, display scaling, ports, and battery life. Apple vs. NVIDIA and the future Mac Pro: They examine the reported driver/signing blockade preventing modern NVIDIA GPUs on Macs and argue that Apple should not hinder third-party GPU support, especially for pro users who expect upgradeable machines. USB4, Thunderbolt, and foldable glass: Two future-facing hardware topics: Corning’s work on flexible glass could enable better foldable devices, while Thunderbolt 3 being folded into USB4 could broaden high-speed I/O across more computers, including future Apple silicon Macs. Apple gaming strategy and subscription bundles: The discussion questions whether Apple should offer a standalone game subscription, noting that iOS games are often cheap/free and that a gaming service makes more sense as part of a broader bundle rather than as a separate purchase. Polestar 2 and the EV market beyond Tesla: In the after-show, the hosts evaluate the Polestar 2 as a serious Tesla competitor, praising Volvo’s EV ambitions and practical car business strengths while criticizing the styling, configurator UX, and first-generation risk.

Key Arguments: Chrome is a good browser technically, but on Mac it behaves in a deeply un-Mac-like, frustrating way and drains laptop battery life. Emergency Chrome updates are hard to find because Chrome hides the obvious update path, despite being aggressive about self-updating. Touch-based drag-and-drop and Springboard rearrangement are inherently error-prone because they require awkward multi-finger precision and have little/no undo. Apple should rely more on usability testing and less on intuition when designing interfaces and gestures. For many low-end or thermally constrained Macs, fewer CPU/RAM options are acceptable because the performance differences are often smaller in real use than marketing suggests. Storage is the most justifiable customization axis because it is a hard limit and expensive, unlike CPU/RAM, which are often soft limits. The Mac Pro should be a true modular platform, and Apple should not block NVIDIA from offering drivers and cards to Mac users. Apple’s apparent hostility toward NVIDIA is especially harmful because NVIDIA remains important in gaming, AI, and pro graphics. A reliable keyboard is the primary line of acceptability for future MacBooks; for some speakers, native-resolution display scaling is also essential. A Mac with more ports, cellular, MagSafe, SD card support, and better battery life would be Apple’s best laptop if it kept the improvements without regression. A separate iOS game subscription is less compelling than a bundle because the iPhone game market is dominated by free/cheap titles and in-app purchases. Polestar/Volvo can be compelling EV competitors, but first-generation electric cars from legacy automakers still pose beta-tester risk.

Data Points: Chrome emergency update urgency: "two or three minutes" - The speaker spent a couple of minutes trying to find how to update Chrome before giving up. Springboard workaround reliability: "at least half the time" - A speaker says the multi-finger drag/drop workaround fails or does the wrong thing about half the time. MacBook Air CPU options: one CPU option - Discussed as evidence that Apple can simplify configurable hardware without controversy. 12-inch MacBook RAM: up to 16 GB - Correction during the discussion that the 12-inch MacBook later gained configurable RAM to 16 GB. iMac Pro CPU range: 6 to 18 cores - Used as an example of a product where broad configurability still makes sense. MacBook Pro keyboard fragility cost: $700 and a week - A speaker estimates repair hassle/cost if dust breaks the keyboard. Mac Pro budget ceiling: not over $6,000 - John’s stated upper limit for the tower itself. Monitor budget ceiling: not over $2,000 - John’s stated upper limit for the display separately. Alternative monitor willingness: $1,800 - John says he would likely choose a 5K monitor if available around this price. MacBook Pro memory usage: 39 GB in use - John reports his current Mac Pro using 39 GB of RAM. Mac Pro memory installed: 64 GB - John notes his machine has 64 GB of RAM total. Mac Pro monitor guess by hosts: $2,000–$3,000 - Speculation about what the forthcoming Apple monitor might cost. Polestar 2 color palette: 6 shades of gray - Criticism that the car only comes in grayscale-like color options. Away suitcase battery: charges a phone up to 5 times - Ad copy describing the suitcase battery capacity.

Pivotal Quotes: "Chrome is so bad. It's so wrong. Everything it does on the Mac is just so wrong." — Marco: Critique of Chrome’s behavior on macOS, especially compared with Safari. "There should be an icon in your toolbar that's like a colored arrow, whether it's green or yellow if you've been waiting a while." — John: Argument that Chrome should make updates more discoverable. "The line of acceptability is basically: have they improved on the current models?" — John: Framework for judging future MacBooks and whether Apple has fixed the current lineup’s problems.

Implications: The episode frames Apple’s future as a tradeoff between simplification and user control: fewer options may be fine if core flaws disappear, but keyboard reliability, GPU openness, and better interfaces remain non-negotiable for pro users.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Accidental Tech Podcast

View all episodes from Accidental Tech Podcast