Animal Spirits Podcast
Animal Spirits Podcast

A 25 Year Bull Market (EP. 420)

On episode 420 of Animal Spirits, ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Michael Batnick⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ and ⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠Ben Carlson⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠⁠ discuss faster recoveries in the stock market, the potential for an even longer bull market, pros and cons of deregulation, zooming out on the dollar, why taxes never rise, a weak jobs market for colleg

Featured Speakers

The Compound Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode ranges from market commentary to policy, labor, housing, and media reviews. Hosts argue the bull market remains broad and healthy despite rapid recoveries, warn deregulation and financial innovation may create future risks, debate Fed policy and tariffs, and highlight how AI, housing scarcity, and rising living costs are reshaping behavior. They also discuss selective movie and TV recommendations.

Main Topics: Market rebound and bull-market breadth (Priority: 5/5): The hosts note stocks have returned to all-time highs quickly after the recent drawdown, arguing the recovery has been unusually fast but still looks healthy beneath the surface. They cite broad participation beyond mega-cap tech, including new highs in financials and industrials, and discuss whether current conditions could support a very long secular bull market. Deregulation, financial innovation, and future risk (Priority: 5/5): A motorcycle-helmet anecdote is used to frame a broader thesis: the pendulum is swinging toward deregulation, which may help innovation but also invite dangerous behavior in financial products. They mention tokenization, private equity in 401(k)s, AI-driven custom investing tools, and leveraged/yield-seeking products as potential sources of future accidents or crises. Fed policy, tariffs, and macro uncertainty (Priority: 4/5): The hosts debate whether Powell was vindicated by the soft landing and improved recession odds. They also revisit tariff announcements and suggest markets may have become desensitized to tariff noise, though companies may still pass costs through more transparently. AI, young workers, and the labor market (Priority: 4/5): They discuss emails from a college career-development professional and a military recruiting anecdote as evidence that young white-collar workers are having a harder time finding entry-level jobs, especially in business-related fields. One host argues this may partly reflect an unusually hot post-COVID labor market rather than an outright crisis. Housing affordability, rates, and family trade-offs (Priority: 5/5): They argue against trying to time housing based on mortgage rates and emphasize that housing decisions are lifestyle choices, not pure investments. A personal story about considering a waterfront home illustrates that higher payments can be worth it for quality-of-life reasons even when spreadsheets say no. They also discuss housing supply shortages and how rate cuts could reignite demand. Rising cost of living and changing consumption patterns (Priority: 4/5): The episode broadens into a reflection on how much better modern life is than in 1776 or the 1980s, while also acknowledging that healthcare, education, childcare, and lifestyle inflation have made life expensive even for high earners. The hosts contrast gratitude for progress with real financial stress among top-income households. Media, movies, and streaming recommendations (Priority: 2/5): The back half includes reviews of recent films and shows such as Jurassic World, Sinners, How to Train Your Dragon, Tires, and several Gerard Butler action movies. They emphasize that box-office success and audience appeal remain difficult to predict, and offer a few personal recommendations and warnings.

Key Arguments: The recent market rebound looks unusually fast, but the internal breadth—especially new highs outside the Mag 7—suggests it is not just a narrow tech rally. Bull markets can be prolonged by major structural innovations and policy backstops; AI may have given the current secular advance a second leg. Deregulation can unleash useful innovation, but it can also create new products and incentives that lead investors to overextend and get hurt. Powell and the Fed should not be judged solely by stock-market outcomes; the soft landing may have been largely driven by the broader economic cycle rather than fine-tuning. Tariffs matter, but markets may no longer react strongly because investors expect reversals or workarounds; firms can simply pass them through as explicit taxes. Young college graduates are facing tougher entry-level white-collar conditions, but some of the apparent weakness may be normalization after an exceptionally hot labor market. Housing should be judged as a lifestyle/psychic decision, not a spreadsheet-only decision; waiting for perfect rates can cause people to miss desirable homes. Healthcare and lifestyle inflation have replaced the old necessities that once dominated budgets, making many households feel squeezed even at high incomes. Private markets may benefit from Vanguard’s entrance because lower fees and scale could improve outcomes for end investors, even if the asset class remains expensive. Public market data and anecdotes about multiple-job holding, drinking, and retirement saving often reflect cyclical or survey effects rather than simple crisis narratives.

Data Points: Days to all-time high after decline: Fastest on record; 2025 example recovered in about 48 days to the low and roughly 80 days to the peak - Used to compare the current rebound to prior bear-market recoveries NASDAQ 100 drawdown: Down 23% at the lows - Recent decline referenced in the market rebound discussion S&P 500 drawdown: Down 19% at the lows - Recent decline referenced in the market rebound discussion Emerging markets drawdown: Down 14% to 15% at the lows - Recent decline referenced in the market rebound discussion European stocks drawdown: Down 14% to 15% at the lows - Recent decline referenced in the market rebound discussion Qs recovery from lows: Up 33% - Performance from the recent bottom through the recording date Emerging markets recovery from lows: Up 26% - Performance from the recent bottom through the recording date European stocks recovery from lows: Up 25% - Performance from the recent bottom through the recording date S&P 500 recovery from lows: Up 25% - Performance from the recent bottom through the recording date Russell 3000 new highs participation: 7% of members made a new 52-week high - Used as evidence of broad market participation Cash Financials exchange fund assets: $500 million - Assets gathered by the newer exchange fund product mentioned in sponsorship copy Cash Financials minimum investment: $100,000 minimum for a year after launch; 60 bps per million - Product pricing details for the exchange fund Dollar decline YTD: Down 10% - Referenced in the discussion of reserve-currency status and FX volumes Dollar share of FX transaction volume: 88% - Used to argue the dollar remains the global reserve currency Recession odds on Polymarket: Peaked near 70%, now around 21% - Used to frame the Fed/recession discussion Young adult unemployment context: Age 20-24 unemployment roughly back to 2000s average - Used in debate over whether young people face a crisis or a normalization after hot labor markets Multiple job holders: Share rises in good times - Described as a pro-cyclical indicator rather than a recession warning Healthcare vs groceries/housing spending: Americans spend more on healthcare than groceries or housing - Illustrates shifting household budget burdens Top-10% household income example: About $350,000 annual income - Wall Street Journal example of households still feeling financially squeezed College costs example: About $75,000 per student per year - Used to explain why high-income families still feel financial pressure New vehicle payments: 19.3% of new-vehicle buyers committed to monthly payments of $1,000+ - Edmunds data showing auto affordability stress Average new vehicle payment: $756 per month - Edmunds data showing elevated auto financing burdens Gen Z retirement saving: 20% are saving for retirement - New York Times story highlighting Gen Z’s early retirement focus Initial baby investment account: $1,000 at birth - Discussion of a new Trump account / baby account concept Potential account growth: About $36,000 to $37,000 by age 18 at 7% return - Tyler Cowen’s estimate for the infant account example Cape Coral home prices: Down 11% in two years - Cited as the worst housing market in America in the article discussed Cape Coral pandemic run-up: Home prices soared 75% in three years - Shows that recent declines do not erase the prior boom Vanguard assets: $10 trillion - Used in the Wall Street Journal discussion of Vanguard entering private markets High school drinking survey (1991): 55% of eighth graders reported drinking - The hosts doubt survey reliability and question the plausibility of the figure High school drinking survey (1991, 12th grade): 78% of 12th graders reported drinking - Used as an example of potentially exaggerated historical survey data Movie box office for Jurassic World Rebirth: $91.5 million Friday-to-Sunday; $147 million Wednesday-to-Sunday; $318 million worldwide - Example of a badly reviewed film still performing strongly at the box office

Pivotal Quotes: "Forget your opinions. I don't care. Just look at what investors are doing as a whole." — Ben: Used to argue the bull market is healthy because breadth and participation are improving "We're entering the wild, wild West for the foreseeable future." — Ben: Commenting on deregulation, private markets, tokenization, and speculative financial products "A house is not a financial investment. It's a psychic investment." — Michael: Explaining why lifestyle value can justify a more expensive waterfront home

Implications: The episode suggests markets remain resilient, but the next risks may come from deregulated financial products, housing scarcity, and AI-driven labor disruption. Investors and consumers should focus on balance, not timing headlines or chasing yield.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Animal Spirits Podcast

Animal Spirits is a show about markets, life, and investing. Join Michael Batnick and Ben Carlson as they talk about what they're reading, writing, listening to and watching. Look for new episodes every Wednesday morning. See our disclosures here - https://ritholtzwealth.com/podcast-youtube-disclosures/

View all episodes from Animal Spirits Podcast