Episode Summary
Executive Summary: Angela Aldrich, co-founder of Bayberry Capital, discusses her journey from Goldman Sachs and Blue Ridge Capital to launching a concentrated long-short hedge fund. She emphasizes the importance of volatility as opportunity, sticking to fundamental research on mid-cap businesses with high quality and asymmetric risk-reward profiles, and maintaining discipline through written theses with signposts to avoid thesis creep. Key examples include WillScot Mobile Mini (a modular office leasing business with surprising free cash flow yields) and Burford Capital (litigation finance with a misunderstood business model and high-quality earnings).
Main Topics: Investment Philosophy and Process (Priority: 5/5): Angela outlines her firm's focus on concentrated portfolios, fundamental primary research, and variant perception. She stresses the need for long-term aligned capital to exploit volatility, sizing positions based on probability-adjusted IRR, and trimming as thesis becomes less variant. The process involves writing clear theses with both bull and bear cases, tracking signposts, and avoiding thesis creep. WillScot Mobile Mini Case Study (Priority: 4/5): A detailed analysis of WillScot, a modular office leasing business. Angela highlights its national scale enabling inventory movement (raising utilization from 60% to 80%), the VAPS value-add service doubling rental revenue, and the resulting hockey-stick free cash flow. The stock was a large long position despite initial short thesis due to high business quality and predictable revenue. Burford Capital Case Study (Priority: 4/5): Burford is litigation finance, funding large corporate cases for a share of outcomes. Angela refutes short thesis claims (accounting, governance), noting 50% of business is from large law firms/corporations, not consumer suits. Key insight: litigation expenses are below free cash flow line, creating misaligned incentives. Burford's YPF case monetization (38% stake sold for 24X) shows high quality and uncorrelated earnings. Volatility as Opportunity (Priority: 3/5): Angela views volatility as a gift enabling opportunistic sizing and trimming. March 2020 drawdown allowed adding to WillScot at low prices. She argues concentration is risk management via deep knowledge, enabling nimble adjustments. Diversification without conviction leads to poor trading and lower returns. Mentorship and Learning (Priority: 2/5): Angela credits John Griffin's mentorship at Blue Ridge for teaching informal weekly lessons, throwing analysts into deep end, and fostering entrepreneurial spirit. She also recommends Carol Dweck's 'Mindset' for growth mindset and Sudhir Venkatesh's 'Gang Leader for a Day' for primary research inspiration. Valuation and Sizing Framework (Priority: 3/5): Angela explains sizing based on probability-adjusted forward IRR, not static multiples. She uses free cash flow yield surprises to drive multiple expansion/contraction. For longs, base cases assume multiple contraction; upside comes from earnings beating consensus. For shorts, thesis must have trackable decline catalysts. Business Quality and Researchability (Priority: 2/5): Angela prefers mid-cap businesses (billion to $8B market cap) with single product/end market, allowing deep fundamental research. She avoids macro-sensitive names (oil, interest rates) and seeks businesses with surprisingly high quality (low cost, necessary, sticky) that are undercovered by sell-side.
Key Arguments: Concentration is risk management: deep knowledge enables nimble adjustments during volatility, while diversification without conviction leads to poor trading. Volatility is opportunity: March 2020 drawdown allowed adding to WillScot at low prices; volatility enables opportunistic sizing and trimming. Thesis must have signposts: written bull and bear cases with data points to track; if thesis not tracking despite stock working, reevaluate. Litigation finance (Burford) is misunderstood: expenses below free cash flow line create misaligned incentives; business is high quality, uncorrelated, and predictable. WillScot's VAPS service doubles rental revenue; national scale enables inventory movement raising utilization from 60% to 80%, creating hockey-stick free cash flow. Sizing based on probability-adjusted forward IRR: largest positions should have highest asymmetry and downside protection, not just upside magnitude. Free cash flow yield surprises drive multiple expansion: if earnings beat consensus significantly, multiples expand; if miss, they contract. Avoid macro predictions: focus on idiosyncratic opportunities; keep macro sensitivities out of portfolio to avoid irrelevant worries.
Data Points: WillScot free cash flow yield: 25% - Trading at 25% free cash flow yield on projections three to five years out, indicating attractive valuation. Burford YPF case monetization: 38% stake sold for $275M (24X return) - Burford sold 38% of its YPF litigation stake for $275 million, achieving a 24X return on that portion. Burford book value concentration: 45% in YPF case - 45% of Burford's book value is concentrated in the YPF litigation, creating perceived binary risk. WillScot VAPS rental increase: ~40% (from $500 to $700/month) - VAPS (value-added services) increases monthly rental from ~$500 to ~$700, nearly doubling underlying rent. WillScot utilization improvement: 60% to 80% - National scale enables moving inventory, raising utilization from 60% to 80%, significantly boosting free cash flow. Blue Ridge portfolio size: ~20 longs, 30-40 shorts - Angela's typical portfolio has about 20 long positions and 30-40 short positions, with largest longs at 10-13% of capital. Burford litigation business mix: 50% large law firms/corporations - 50% of Burford's business is from large law firms and corporations, not consumer class actions.
Pivotal Quotes: "Volatility is opportunity. Opportunity often feels like a punch in the face." — Angela Aldrich: Discussing how volatility creates opportunities to buy names at depressed prices, like March 2020. "Concentration is risk management. If you have a concentrated portfolio where you can be more in the weeds, it allows you to be nimble." — Angela Aldrich: Explaining why concentration with deep knowledge is a form of risk management, enabling quick adjustments. "The best investors always ask themselves whether they're making money for the right reasons." — Angela Aldrich (citing Ken Daniel): Emphasizing the need to distinguish luck from skill and avoid self-attribution bias. "We invest on evidence, not prediction." — Angela Aldrich: Stating the firm's reliance on trackable data points and signposts rather than forecasting. "If you can't understand why people don't see your perspective, it's really hard to unlock value." — Angela Aldrich: Highlighting the importance of understanding the other side's thesis to forecast price movement.
Implications: Angela's approach demonstrates that concentrated, research-driven long-short investing with long-term aligned capital can thrive in volatile markets. Her emphasis on fundamental quality, asymmetric risk-reward, and thesis discipline offers a blueprint for navigating uncertainty. The Burford and WillScot cases show how misunderstood businesses with high free cash flow yields can be mispriced, providing opportunities for patient investors. Listeners should focus on developing variant views, tracking signposts, and sizing positions based on probability-adjusted returns rather than chasing macro trends.
About Value Investing with Legends
Value investing is more than an investment strategy — it's a fundamental way of thinking about finance. Value investing was developed in the 1920s at Columbia Business School by professors Benjamin Graham and David Dodd, MS '21. The authors of the classic text, Security Analysis, Graham and Dodd were the very pioneers of their field and their security analysis principles provided the first rational basis for investment decisions. Despite the vast and volatile changes in the economy and securities markets during the last several decades, value investing has proven to be the most successful money management strategy ever developed. Value investors' success over the second half of the twentieth century proved not only the validity of the value approach, but its preeminence over even the most widely taught and practiced modern investment theory, which was developed in the 1950s and '60s and remains dominant even today. Our mission today is to promote the study and practice of Graham & Dodd's original investing principles and to improve investing with world-class education, research, and practitioner-academic dialogue. In this podcast you will hear from some of the world's greatest investors, their views on the investment management industry, how they developed their investment process and how they see the field changing over time.