Episode Summary
Executive Summary: The episode centers on Ben Shapiro’s critique of Time naming Trump Person of the Year, arguing the cover art and title subtly reflect media bias and America’s existing divisions. He then evaluates Trump’s early cabinet picks as mostly strong while warning that Trump’s real governing style is likely to be his own erratic, deal-driven behavior—not his appointees. The show also attacks left-wing reactions to Trump, media hypocrisy, and identity politics.
Main Topics: Time magazine’s Trump cover and media framing (Priority: 5/5): Shapiro argues Time’s 2016 Trump cover intentionally casts Trump as a gangster and frames him as the president of a “divided states” America, contrasting that with the more celebratory Obama covers from 2008 and 2012. Left-wing overreaction to Trump’s victory (Priority: 4/5): He ridicules emotional responses among liberals—especially Valerie Jarrett and a New York Magazine piece about women changing hair color—as proof of childish, exaggerated mourning rather than serious political analysis. Trump cabinet picks: strengths and weaknesses (Priority: 5/5): Shapiro praises several early appointments, especially James Mattis, Scott Pruitt, John Kelly, and Andy Puzder, while criticizing picks like Bannon, Flynn, and Ben Carson. He sees the cabinet as largely competent but not decisive for Trump’s true governing style. Trump’s deal-making and use of presidential power (Priority: 5/5): He argues Trump’s real governing pattern is his personal intervention with companies and public pressure via Twitter, citing Carrier and Boeing as examples of potentially coercive, inconsistent, and anti–rule of law behavior. Media and Democratic hypocrisy (Priority: 4/5): Shapiro says the left and media falsely claim Republicans alone divide the country while ignoring Obama-era polarization and their own prior objections to Obama’s use of power against critics like Fox News and Rush Limbaugh. Republican ideological shift toward state intervention (Priority: 4/5): He highlights polling showing many Republicans now accept direct presidential negotiation with companies, targeted tax incentives, and contracts, which he views as a dangerous abandonment of free-market principles. Biblical reflection on trust and monuments (Priority: 2/5): The episode ends with a Torah reading discussion about Jacob, Laban, and the difference between monuments to God and deals with men, used as a metaphor for the danger of trusting human power over principle.
Key Arguments: Time’s cover art is not neutral; it visually encodes ideological narratives about Obama as transcendent and Trump as sinister. The country was already divided before Trump, and Obama’s presidency did not produce national unity. Left-wing emotional breakdowns after the election are evidence of political immaturity, not principled resistance. Trump’s cabinet selections are often more competent than the surrounding rhetoric suggests, but cabinet quality does not determine Trump’s actual behavior. Trump’s personal tweets and public company targeting are more predictive of his presidency than his appointees are. Using presidential power to single out businesses or critics is inconsistent with limited-government conservatism and mirrors tactics once condemned under Obama. Republicans are increasingly willing to embrace interventionist, crony-capitalist policies simply because Trump endorses them. Democrats could exploit Trump’s interventionist instincts by offering more of the same, but instead they keep leaning on identity politics and accusations of racism. The right response to political power is skepticism toward all politicians, not selective trust in one's preferred leader.
Data Points: Time Person of the Year (2016): Donald Trump - Opening segment discussing the Time magazine announcement Time Person of the Year (2012): Barack Obama - Used as a contrast with Trump and discussed alongside the cover art Time Person of the Year (2008): Barack Obama - Referenced as another contrasting Obama cover Number of magazines in Texture subscription: 200 - Advertisement for Texture.com Texture monthly price: $9.99/month - Texture subscription pitch Texture trial length: 14 days free - Promotional offer at Texture.com/Ben Scott Pruitt on climate disagreement: Scientists continue to disagree about the degree and extent of global warming - Quote cited to justify Pruitt’s EPA nomination Boeing Air Force One contract claim: More than $4 billion - Trump tweet criticized as inaccurate by Shapiro Boeing current contract figure: $170 million - Shapiro cites reporting that contradicts Trump’s claim Carrier jobs claimed saved: 1,100 - Trump’s public claim about Carrier Carrier jobs still moving to Mexico: 550 - Union leader’s on-air correction Carrier jobs in Huntington facility going to Mexico: 700 - Union leader’s on-air correction SoftBank U.S. investment promise: $50 billion - Trump tweet praising SoftBank after the election SoftBank jobs promise: 50,000 new jobs - Trump tweet praising SoftBank after the election U.S. Steel possible return of jobs: Close to 10,000 - CEO says optimism could bring jobs back under Trump Republicans who agree free market has been sorting economy out and America has been losing: 57% - Polling cited to show GOP shift away from free-market beliefs Independents agreeing with the same statement: 38% - Polling comparison Democrats agreeing with the same statement: 33% - Polling comparison Republicans who say it is fine for president and vice president to directly negotiate with private businesses: 69% - Polling on interventionist economic views Republicans who think it is okay to offer tax breaks or incentives to individual companies: 78% - Polling on targeted corporate policy Republicans who say government offering contracts to individual companies is fine: 71% - Polling on crony-capitalist interventions Republicans who say president may negotiate with private companies case-by-case: 75% - Polling on Trump-style governance support Urban vote for Clinton: 59% - Statistical rebuttal to claims that Trump support was simply racial backlash Rural vote for Trump: 62% - Statistical rebuttal to claims that Trump support was simply racial backlash Counties with highest college-degree share voting for Clinton: +26% margin - Education-based voting pattern cited by Shapiro Counties with lowest college-degree share voting for Trump: +31% margin - Education-based voting pattern cited by Shapiro
Pivotal Quotes: "President of the divided states of America" — Narrator/Ben Shapiro: Description of Time’s 2016 Trump cover and its implied framing "This election deadened my soul." — New York Magazine subject quoted by Shapiro: Example of what Shapiro portrays as extreme liberal overreaction "The free market has been sorting the economy out and America has been losing." — Polling prompt quoted by Shapiro: Used to illustrate Republican drift toward protectionism and intervention
Implications: Listeners are urged to distrust media framing, reject personality-based loyalty to politicians, and scrutinize Trump’s actual behavior rather than his appointees. The episode suggests both parties are drifting toward identity politics and state intervention, with major consequences for conservatism and economic policy.
About The Ben Shapiro Show
Tired of the lies? Tired of the spin? Are you ready to hear the hard-hitting truth in comprehensive, conservative, principled fashion? The Ben Shapiro Show brings you all the news you need to know in the most fast moving daily program in America. Ben brutally breaks down the culture and never gives an inch! Monday thru Friday.