Episode Summary
Executive Summary: The episode centers on Ben Shapiro’s praise of Donald Trump’s nomination of Neil Gorsuch to the Supreme Court, arguing it fulfills a key campaign promise and restores constitutional textualism. Shapiro sharply criticizes the New York Times and Democratic reactions as exaggerated and hypocritical, while cautioning conservatives not to give Trump a pass on other policies. He also reflects on media culture, executive power, and closes with a Bible discussion on faith and the Exodus.
Main Topics: Neil Gorsuch Supreme Court nomination (Priority: 5/5): Shapiro argues Gorsuch is an outstanding, principled textualist whose record suggests fidelity to the Constitution, citing his rulings on religious liberty, the death penalty, the Second Amendment, and Chevron deference. Critique of the New York Times editorial (Priority: 5/5): He mocks the Times for calling Gorsuch extreme and portraying Senate Republican obstruction as illegitimate, saying the paper is upset about losing a liberal judicial majority. Trump’s political strategy and conservative leverage (Priority: 4/5): Shapiro says the nomination gives Trump political capital and could help him press for other priorities, but conservatives should not be lulled into supporting bad policies like tariffs or massive spending. Democratic overreaction and filibuster politics (Priority: 4/5): He describes Democratic responses as hysterical and strategically shortsighted, arguing they should save the filibuster fight for a future swing-seat nomination instead of exhausting it on Gorsuch. Media hypocrisy and celebrity politics (Priority: 3/5): The show critiques the media and late-night comedy for helping create the Trump-era political environment through sensationalism and fake-news style commentary, while failing to understand the source of their own frustration. Power, competence, and government skepticism (Priority: 3/5): Shapiro argues that both supporters and opponents often inflate political leaders into all-powerful masterminds, when in reality most officials are simply incompetent; he uses this to advocate shrinking government power. Biblical lesson from Parsha Bo (Priority: 3/5): The Torah portion is used to explain faith, obedience, and acting as though divine promises are already unfolding, especially through the Passover lamb and matzah commandments.
Key Arguments: Gorsuch is a strong textualist with a coherent constitutional philosophy, making him a superior Supreme Court pick for conservatives. The Senate has constitutional authority to withhold a vote or filibuster; Republican tactics are not inherently illegitimate. Democrats are overstating the dangers of Gorsuch because they are losing a judicial power struggle, not because his nomination is outside historical norms. Trump’s appointment is a real win for conservatives, but it does not justify endorsing his other policy choices automatically. If Democrats are strategic, they should conserve the filibuster for a more important future Supreme Court nomination. Media and political elites often exaggerate leaders into either heroes or villains, when most governing is just ordinary incompetence. The Torah’s Exodus narrative teaches faith by requiring action before the expected deliverance is complete.
Data Points: Supreme Court seat: 1 - Neil Gorsuch was nominated to fill the late Justice Antonin Scalia’s seat. Circuit court confirmation vote: unanimous voice vote in 2006 - Shapiro notes Gorsuch was unanimously confirmed to the Tenth Circuit, with Obama and Biden in the Senate. Presidential election popular-vote margin referenced: nearly 3 million votes - Shapiro mentions Trump’s popular-vote loss to Hillary Clinton while discussing media criticism. Trump presidency duration referenced: 10 days - He says it is too early to judge the presidency overall because it is only about 10 days old. Democratic protest rallies: about 75 cities - Referenced in Tim Kaine’s remarks about rallies against Trump policies. Infrastructure package size referenced: $1 trillion - Shapiro speculates Trump might seek a trillion-dollar infrastructure deal as political bargaining leverage. Meal offer from Blue Apron ad: 3 free meals - Sponsor mention included an offer for three free meals with shipping. Meal price from Blue Apron ad: less than $10 per person per meal - Sponsor mention describing the service’s affordability. Cooking time from Blue Apron ad: less than 40 minutes - Sponsor mention describing how long meals take to prepare. Biblical text reference: Exodus 12:5-8 - The Torah portion includes instructions for the Passover lamb and matzah.
Pivotal Quotes: "I have never been happier to be wrong." — Ben Shapiro: His reaction to Donald Trump nominating Neil Gorsuch, after having predicted Trump would not pick a true textualist. "If Judge Gorsuch is confirmed, the court will once again have a majority of justices appointed by Republican presidents." — The New York Times (quoted by Shapiro): Used to illustrate Shapiro’s claim that the Times is really upset about losing ideological control of the Court. "I pledge that if I am confirmed, I will do all my powers permit to be a faithful servant of the Constitution and laws of this great country." — Neil Gorsuch: Quoted from Gorsuch’s introduction to emphasize his constitutionalist framing.
Implications: The episode frames Gorsuch’s nomination as a major conservative victory and a test of Senate strategy, while warning listeners not to confuse one good outcome with blanket approval of Trump. It also reinforces Shapiro’s broader theme: limit government power, distrust media panic, and judge politics by results, not rhetoric.
About The Ben Shapiro Show
Tired of the lies? Tired of the spin? Are you ready to hear the hard-hitting truth in comprehensive, conservative, principled fashion? The Ben Shapiro Show brings you all the news you need to know in the most fast moving daily program in America. Ben brutally breaks down the culture and never gives an inch! Monday thru Friday.