Deep Questions with Cal Newport
Deep Questions with Cal Newport

Ep. 369: Why Are We Getting Dumber? A Debate.

IQ scores had been steadily rising since WWII. But, more recently, this phenomenon has stopped. Since 2010, we’ve actually been getting dumber. In this episode, Cal gets into the common theories for why this is true before offering his own take, which leads to some practical takeaways to help you th

Featured Speakers

Cal Newport Guest

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: Cal Newport argues that IQ declines reflect a “reverse Flynn effect” driven by two forces: declining reading/literate culture and smartphones’ destruction of sustained attention. He supports this with recent IQ studies, then pivots to practical advice: quit attention-extractive apps, use “attention resistance” for necessary tools, keep phones out of reach at home, train focus daily, and adopt stronger work/planning systems.

Main Topics: Reverse Flynn Effect and IQ Decline (Priority: 5/5): The episode opens with evidence that measured IQ scores, after decades of rising, began declining in the 2010s across multiple studies and demographics. Post-Literacy Hypothesis (Priority: 5/5): New media replaced reading as the dominant information format, weakening analytic thought, reasoning, and the kind of disciplined processing favored by IQ tests. Smartphones and Attention Loss (Priority: 5/5): Cal adds that smartphones and algorithmic content intensify the problem by eroding concentration, making people less able to use existing cognitive capacity. Practical Attention Strategies (Priority: 5/5): He recommends deleting attention-extractive apps, using tools to neutralize addictive features, keeping phones in a fixed location at home, and training attention through focused work and solitude. Productivity, Deep Work, and Project Recovery (Priority: 4/5): Listener Q&A covers how to resume deep work after interruptions, how to structure work with ticketing systems, and how to use time-blocking, quotas, and evidence-based planning. Schools and Cell Phone Bans (Priority: 4/5): Cal notes broad bipartisan momentum for school phone bans and argues the main remaining resistance comes from anxious parents, not educators or researchers. Case Study on Creative Focus (Priority: 4/5): A songwriter’s success story shows how one-hour daily deep work sessions on a single project can produce major creative breakthroughs and faster long-term output.

Key Arguments: IQ decline appears real in multiple studies, with the inflection point around the 2010s rather than a single dataset anomaly. The post-literacy shift explains part of the decline: fewer books and less print-based reasoning weaken analytical habits over time. Smartphones add a second mechanism: they reduce the ability to sustain concentration, so people can’t fully use whatever cognitive ability they still have. The sharpest IQ declines among 18–22-year-olds support the smartphone hypothesis because that cohort was raised with phones during schooling and uses them most heavily. Attention is trainable; reducing digital distractions can yield relatively higher performance even if the broader trend continues. Most work environments still rely on interrupt-driven communication, but ticketing systems and communication protocols can reduce cognitive switching costs. School phone bans are increasingly supported by teachers and policymakers; parental anxiety is now a major barrier. Long, consistent, low-drama deep work beats sporadic bursts of intense effort for creative and professional outcomes.

Data Points: Reverse Flynn effect study window: Declines begin roughly between 2006 and 2012 - Multiple IQ studies show scores turning downward in the 2010s IQ trend in older data: +3 to +5 IQ points per decade - Approximate historical gain cited for charts from 1932 onward Test used in Northwestern paper: 35-item composite ICAR test - Chart showing downward IQ trends across education levels Education groups in chart: Graduate education to less than 12 years of schooling - All education strata trend downward Gender effect: No meaningful difference - Both male and female IQ lines decline similarly 3D spatial reasoning: One measure still increasing - The only subtest mentioned as not declining Age group with sharpest decline: 18 to 22-year-olds - In the Northwestern study, this cohort fell fastest after 2010 Reading decline timing: Started in the 1980s and 1990s - Reading rates fell well before smartphones became ubiquitous Phone-ban state examples: At least 8 other states - In addition to New York, states like Florida and Louisiana have restrictions California policy deadline: July 2026 - Every district must devise a smartphone-limiting policy by then Sponsored jobs stat: 45% more applications - Indeed-sponsored jobs on Indeed compared with non-sponsored jobs OCI cost claims: Up to 50% less for compute, 70% less for storage, 80% less for networking - Oracle Cloud Infrastructure ad copy Vanta productivity stat: Over $500,000 a year in cost and 3x more productive - IDC study cited in sponsor segment Deep work case study timing: 2.5 months - Songwriter solved a difficult lyric puzzle through one-hour daily sessions Newsletter subscriber count: Over 70,000 - Cal mentions his newsletter audience

Pivotal Quotes: "We’re in a post-literacy society, but also a post-concentration society." — Cal Newport: Core thesis tying together declining reading and smartphone-driven attention loss "If you quit apps where people make money off you... you’ll be getting relatively smarter." — Cal Newport: Concrete takeaway about removing attention-extractive apps "The greatest gift you could give to a teenager at home... is keep your phone in the kitchen." — Cal Newport: Advice on family phone rules and focus restoration

Implications: Listeners are urged to treat attention as a competitive advantage: reduce addictive digital inputs, structure work to preserve focus, and push for phone-free schools. The broader message is that even if society trends toward lower attention, individuals can still outperform by building focus intentionally.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Deep Questions with Cal Newport

View all episodes from Deep Questions with Cal Newport