Science Friday
Science Friday

Fundamentals of Physics, Giant Ancient Birds, 2021 Space Outlook. Jan 8, 2021, Part 2

Finding New Particles On The Frontier of Physics As a theoretical physicist, Frank Wilczek has made a career out of dreaming up new ways to understand our physical universe—and he’s usually right. In the early 1980’s, he predicted the existence of a new quasiparticle, called the anyon—which was conf

Featured Speakers

Frank Wilczek Guest

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode opens with a look ahead at a packed 2021 for space exploration: SpaceX’s crewed NASA missions, Boeing’s Starliner reset, the James Webb Telescope launch, Mars missions, civilian spaceflight, and China’s new station. It then shifts to physicist Frank Wilczek on new physics ideas, axions, AI, climate and nuclear risks, and the early universe. The final segment examines fossil evidence showing giant toothed seabirds evolved early and vanished with climate cooling.

Main Topics: A banner year for space exploration in 2021 (Priority: 5/5): Ira Flato and Christian Davenport outline how 2021 could be unusually active for spaceflight, with NASA, private companies, Mars missions, telescope launches, and tourism all on the calendar. SpaceX’s expanding role in human spaceflight and beyond (Priority: 5/5): SpaceX is restoring U.S. crew launches, preparing more NASA missions, developing Starship for deep-space travel, and building Starlink as a global internet constellation. Boeing’s delayed astronaut transport and Moon rocket duties (Priority: 4/5): Boeing’s Starliner faced a major software failure in 2019, forcing a redo test flight before astronauts can fly, while Boeing also leads NASA’s Space Launch System lunar rocket project. James Webb Telescope and Mars mission surge (Priority: 5/5): The James Webb Space Telescope is expected to finally launch, while NASA, the UAE, and China each plan Mars missions during the narrow planetary launch window. Commercial spaceflight and space tourism (Priority: 4/5): Virgin Galactic, Blue Origin, and Axiom/SpaceX are pushing civilian access to suborbital trips and private missions to the International Space Station, though costs remain very high. Frank Wilczek on new physics, AI, and cosmic origins (Priority: 5/5): Wilczek discusses eneons, axions, gravitons, the relationship between mind and matter, AI as a gradual crossover rather than a sudden singularity, and the limits of current cosmology. Giant prehistoric birds and museum-based discovery (Priority: 4/5): A later segment explains how museum fossils helped show pelagornithids reached giant size earlier than thought, and how climate cooling likely contributed to their extinction.

Key Arguments: 2021 was expected to be a major year for space because delayed programs from 2020 were still moving forward and several major missions were clustered together. SpaceX had largely restored U.S. human spaceflight from Kennedy Space Center after a nearly decade-long gap, and was becoming central to NASA crew transport. Starship represents SpaceX’s long-term ambition to send humans to the Moon and Mars, while Starlink is a separate but massive infrastructure project. Boeing’s Starliner failure showed that legacy aerospace firms could stumble badly in software and integration, delaying NASA’s backup crewed transportation system. The James Webb Telescope is a high-cost, high-stakes successor to Hubble, with scientists believing launch readiness is finally near after years of delay. Mars 2021 launches are significant because the orbital window comes only about every 26 months, making multiple missions in one month especially notable. Civilian spaceflight is moving from fantasy to real market, with suborbital tourism and private orbital missions now in development, though prices limit access. Wilczek argues that eneons expand the known particle families beyond bosons and fermions in two-dimensional settings, and that experimental evidence has now appeared. He believes axions are a plausible dark matter candidate and that many researchers are actively building detection methods and antenna concepts for them. Wilczek sees AI not as an overnight singularity but as a gradual shift toward an ecology of intelligence involving humans, computers, and autonomous systems. He emphasizes that climate change and nuclear weapons are dangers produced by human mastery of physics, so scientific progress must be paired with responsibility. The pelagornithid research shows museum collections can contain major discoveries for decades before researchers reexamine them with fresh questions and better context. The fossil record suggests these giant seabirds evolved their huge wingspans relatively quickly after appearing and likely went extinct when global temperatures fell. Antarctica’s fossil record reveals it was once much warmer and biologically richer, supporting birds, frogs, marsupials, and other fauna now absent there.

Data Points: Space Shuttle retirement gap: Nearly a decade - NASA had not flown astronauts from U.S. soil since the shuttle retired in 2011 until SpaceX resumed crewed launches in 2020. Crew-2 mission astronauts: 4 - SpaceX’s next NASA crewed mission to the ISS was described as carrying four astronauts. SpaceX Starlink satellites already in orbit: About 1,000 - By the time of the interview, SpaceX had already placed roughly a thousand Starlink satellites in orbit. FCC contract for Starlink: More than $800 million - SpaceX won an FCC contract to help advance broadband satellite deployment. NASA contract for Starship: More than $100 million - NASA invested in SpaceX’s Starship program for future lunar and Mars ambitions. Boeing Starliner test flight software offset: 11 hours off - The 2019 Starliner test flight suffered a software issue that caused the spacecraft to think it was 11 hours into a different mission phase. James Webb Telescope cost: $9 billion - Wilczek and Davenport described Webb as a costly Hubble successor poised for launch. James Webb distance from Earth: 1 million miles - The telescope will operate far beyond Earth orbit at the Sun-Earth L2 region. Mars launch window interval: About every 26 months - Three Mars missions were planned in a single month because launches to Mars are only practical during this alignment window. Perseverance landing site: Jezero Crater - NASA’s rover Perseverance was set to land in Jezero Crater to look for signs of life. Ingenuity helicopter: 1 - Perseverance carries one small helicopter, Ingenuity, for the first powered flight on Mars. Virgin Galactic ticket price: $250,000 - The company planned suborbital space tourism flights at this approximate price, though it may rise. Private ISS trip estimate: About $50 million - Axiom/SpaceX civilian trips to the ISS were estimated at around this amount for a 10-day stay. Pelagornithid age range: 62 million to 2-3 million years ago - The giant bony-toothed birds existed for roughly 60 million years, from shortly after the dinosaur extinction until near the Pleistocene. Giant pelagornithid wingspan: About 6 meters / 20 feet - The largest birds discussed reached enormous wingspans, far larger than modern seabirds. Early pelagornithid wingspan: About 3 feet - The oldest known individuals were much smaller, roughly gull-sized. Antarctic gigantism timing: About 50 million years ago - Museum fossils indicated giant body size evolved earlier than previously believed. Big Bang age: About 13.7 billion years - Wilczek summarized the standard cosmological timeline for the universe’s origin and evolution. Cosmology limit: About one microsecond old - Wilczek said our equations are secure only back to roughly this point before they break down.

Pivotal Quotes: "2021 is promising to be a banner year." — Ira Flato: Opening frame for the space-exploration segment. "I think it's not going to happen that one night you go to bed and your computer is kind of dopey, and the next morning you find that it's telling you what to do and turning you off, or something." — Frank Wilczek: Wilczek rejecting a sudden AI singularity in favor of gradual change. "The sky's the limit." — Peter Close: On the search for the next major pelagornithid fossil discovery.

Implications: Listeners get a snapshot of a pivotal year for spaceflight and science: reusable launch systems, commercial access to orbit, and major cosmic missions, alongside a reminder that discovery often comes from revisiting old collections and that climate change can reshape entire lineages.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Science Friday

View all episodes from Science Friday