Intelligence Squared
Intelligence Squared

How to Win Every Game, with Marcus du Sautoy, Part Two

Where should you move first in Connect 4? Which property is best in Monopoly? How can pi help you win Rock Paper Scissors? In October 2024 award-winning mathematician Marcus du Sautoy came to the Intelligence Squared stage to explore the maths and strategy behind the games we love and the tactics ne

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: Marcus du Sautoy argues that games are social, cultural, and mathematical systems that reveal how people communicate, compete, and innovate. He explores gendered shifts in game design, cheating as a built-in mechanic, strategies for winning Monopoly, and how AI and machine learning are transforming games like Go—while defending board games as a vital social counterweight to digital play.

Main Topics: Gender, social play, and the evolution from Whist to Bridge (Priority: 5/5): Du Sautoy explains that Bridge emerged from Whist partly because players enjoyed the communicative, coded bidding phase, which made the game more social and helped attract more women into play. Women game designers and new game aesthetics (Priority: 4/5): He highlights a newer wave of women developers bringing different themes and styles—especially nature, cooperation, and story—exemplified by Wingspan, which replaces war/goblin/castle tropes with bird sanctuaries. Cheating as a feature of game design (Priority: 5/5): He argues that some games evolve by absorbing cheating-like signals into accepted play, as in Truco and Monopoly’s cheat edition, showing that rule-bending can become part of the fun and strategy. Mathematical strategy and winning Monopoly (Priority: 5/5): Du Sautoy gives a probabilistic strategy for Monopoly centered on jail and the orange properties, using dice probabilities and board traffic to explain why some spaces are more profitable. What makes a good game (Priority: 5/5): He defines good games as ones that mix chance and strategy, keep all players engaged, and avoid being decided before play begins; he contrasts this with chess and overly long games like Monopoly. AI, machine learning, and creativity in games (Priority: 5/5): He describes how AlphaGo marked a shift from top-down coding to machine learning, arguing that AI can generate genuinely creative moves that change how humans play and think about games. The future of games: digital vs physical (Priority: 4/5): He contrasts solitary early video games with the renewed popularity of social board games, emphasizing that physical, around-the-table play remains important even in the digital age.

Key Arguments: Games are deeply social; the communicative element can be as important as the competition itself, as shown by Bridge’s evolution from Whist. Women entering game development are broadening the medium’s themes and mechanics, moving beyond traditional warfare and fantasy aesthetics. Cheating is not always antithetical to games; in some contexts, it is formalized and becomes part of legitimate play. Monopoly can be approached mathematically: jail is highly trafficked, and the orange properties are strategically strong because many players exit jail and land there. A good game should blend chance and strategy so that beginners still have a path to victory and the outcome is not predetermined. Pure strategy games risk becoming stale or “solved,” while mixed games remain engaging because uncertainty persists. AI represents a major revolution in game-playing code because machine learning allows systems to discover novel moves rather than merely follow prewritten instructions. AlphaGo’s unusual move in game two, move 37, demonstrated that AI can expand human strategic imagination rather than simply outperform humans. Board games are resurging because people want social, tactile experiences that contrast with solitary digital gaming. Scrabble and other ostensibly word-based games are still strongly shaped by mathematical optimization and strategy.

Data Points: Monopoly jail visitation frequency: 3 times more likely than any other square - Du Sautoy says jail is visited three times more often than any other space on the Monopoly board. Dice outcome probability: 1 in 36 - He cites the probability of rolling a 1 on both dice as an example of why some totals are rare. AlphaGo match result: 4 games to 1 - He describes Lee Sedol losing four of five games to AlphaGo. AlphaGo move reference: Move 37 in game 2 - He identifies this move as the moment AI seemed creatively surprising to human experts. Age of a modern board-game player: 28 - He mentions his son is 28 and now enjoys gathering with friends to play board games. Timeframe of AI revolution: About 10 years - He says machine learning has been transforming code for roughly a decade.

Pivotal Quotes: "one of my other rules of a good game is it shouldn't finish before it starts" — Marcus du Sautoy: He is explaining that a good game should not have a predetermined outcome. "this is my latest move in the Glass Bead game" — Marcus du Sautoy: He describes his book as a synthesis of mathematics, history, culture, philosophy, art, and literature. "I think that's why pure strategy games... are destroyed if somebody discovers a perfect way to play the game" — Marcus du Sautoy: He is arguing that perfect information or solved games lose some of their appeal.

Implications: Listeners are encouraged to see games as mirrors of society and engines of innovation. The episode suggests that social design, inclusivity, and AI-driven creativity will shape the next era of play.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Intelligence Squared

View all episodes from Intelligence Squared