This Week in Startups
This Week in Startups

Jason Mentors The Next Generation + Why AI Is Bad at Teaching (Aristotle Interview) | E2346

This Week In Startups is made possible by: Vanta: https://www.vanta.com/twist DigitalOcean: https://do.co/twist Sentry: http://sentry.io/twist Plaud: http://Plaud.ai/twist Today’s show: The smarter AI gets, the more it just does the work for you, and the less helpful it becomes as a tutor. Shan Redd

Featured Speakers

Jason Calacanis Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: This episode centers on “Ask Jason” advice for students, founders, and AI builders, plus a featured interview with Aristotle, an AI tutoring startup. Jason urges students to use AI first, read biographies broadly, and build practical skills through projects. He also argues AI tutoring can outperform traditional schooling by delivering personalized, multimodal instruction, while emphasizing trust, customer discovery, and the psychology of frontier AI labs.

Main Topics: Student advice: AI-first learning and biography reading (Priority: 5/5): Jason advises college-bound callers to use AI as a superpower for learning finance and career prep, and to read at least one biography a month to build worldly judgment and pattern recognition. Using money and opportunity to build skills or companies (Priority: 5/5): When asked what to do with $500K, Jason frames it as a choice between investing in yourself, starting projects/companies, or making angel/public-market investments—while emphasizing that entrepreneurship often matters more than capital. Customer discovery and startup research tactics (Priority: 4/5): Jason explains practical, sometimes indirect ways to reach decision-makers and gather feedback, including interview incentives, market research fronts, and using AI/bots to scale outreach. AI doomerism and frontier lab motivations (Priority: 4/5): Jason argues that AI safety rhetoric may be partly sincere and partly strategic, but also reflects a genuine belief among some lab leaders that they are creating something like consciousness or 'God in a box.' Aristotle: AI tutor for personalized education (Priority: 5/5): A deep dive into Aristotle’s product, business model, and technical approach: a voice-based AI tutor that adapts to student needs, emphasizes productive struggle, and aims to replicate high-quality one-on-one tutoring. Education system limits and AI’s role in schools (Priority: 4/5): Jason and the founder discuss how AI tutoring can supplement teachers, help dyslexic students, and free schools to focus more on social, emotional, and physical development rather than just curriculum delivery. Data, privacy, and defensibility in edtech (Priority: 4/5): The founders discuss building proprietary tutoring data, training internal evals, and keeping student data locked down, while also recognizing the competitive risks from large AI labs and model providers.

Key Arguments: AI-first learning is the best hedge for students entering fast-changing fields like finance; AI should be used to identify gaps, build models, and self-teach advanced topics. Reading biographies is a high-leverage way to understand industries, leadership styles, and historical context without needing to 'network' for every lesson. If given capital, a young person should think in terms of skill-building, projects, angel investing, or starting a company—not merely consuming money as runway. Entrepreneurship requires learning every operational function, from taxes and NDAs to payroll and sales, not just a narrow job function. Customer discovery should be aggressive and practical; founders should get in front of users by any legal means necessary to learn the market. Some AI safety/doomer narratives may reflect both sincere concern and strategic incentives from frontier labs that are discovering how powerful their systems are. General-purpose LLMs are not inherently optimized for teaching; education requires specialized pedagogy, multimodal interaction, and the right next teaching action. One-on-one tutoring is still the gold standard for learning, and AI can finally scale it at accessible prices. The best edtech products will likely combine tutoring with teacher support, dashboards, and classroom integration rather than replacing schools outright. Student data from tutoring sessions is valuable for improving models, but must be protected carefully, especially for minors.

Data Points: Fordham annual cost: $80,000 a year all in - Jason describes Fordham as highly expensive and competitive during the first caller’s college planning discussion. Pell Grants received by Jason: About $10,000 - Jason recalls financing his own Fordham education with limited government aid and payment plans. Tuition Jason paid: $11,000 a year - Jason describes the cost of Fordham when he attended. Biographies assignment: 10 per year - Jason tells callers to read roughly one biography a month to broaden perspective. Suggested caller reading list: 5 biographies - Jason assigns the callers to read five biographies and report back with insights. AI tutoring demand age range: 13 to 18 years old - Aristotle says most U.S. tutoring demand comes from teens preparing for exams and college. Aristotle pricing: $50/month for 8 sessions; $199 for unlimited access - The founder explains the subscription model and session packs. Aristotle reported usage: 60+ hours per month - Some students on the unlimited plan reportedly use the tutor extensively. Student tutoring prevalence: Less than 1 out of every 52 U.S. students - Aristotle cites the rarity of personal tutoring and the scale problem in education. Bloom’s two-sigma finding: 2 sigma improvement - Referenced as the famous benchmark for one-on-one tutoring outcomes. Sentry usage: 4 million developers - Sponsor mention in the ad read describing Sentry’s developer base. Vanta customer count: 16,000+ companies - Sponsor mention during the trust/compliance ad read. Character AI on DigitalOcean: Over 1 billion queries per day - DigitalOcean ad cites Character AI’s usage and cost reduction. DigitalOcean cost reduction: Up to 50% - The ad claims AI workload costs can be reduced by up to half. Character AI token cost reduction: Cut cost per token in half - Example of DigitalOcean infrastructure efficiency. Subscriber/student pricing equivalence: ~$6 per session (derived from $50/8 sessions) - Jason breaks down Aristotle’s pricing during the interview. Teacher support context: One-on-one tutoring is best for thousands of years - Foundational claim used to justify the product thesis.

Pivotal Quotes: "Anything they try to teach you, you're going to go to AI first and say, here's what my teacher wants to teach me. How do I use AI to be superhuman at this?" — Jason: Advice to a Fordham-bound finance student on becoming AI-first in college and career preparation. "What you want to be is unstoppable that you can do every single thing from your taxes to negotiating a non-disclosure agreement from starting an LLC, doing your payroll." — Jason: Jason explains what real entrepreneurship requires when discussing what to do with $500K. "We're not trying to actually build anything new. We're trying to just deliver in software the one-on-one tutoring experience that has been known to be the best way to learn for literally thousands of years." — Sean Reddy: Aristotle CEO describing the product’s core mission and pedagogical philosophy.

Implications: For students and founders, AI is a force multiplier if used actively rather than passively. For edtech, the opportunity is to personalize learning at scale, but winning will require proprietary pedagogy, strong data practices, and trust with parents, schools, and regulators.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About This Week in Startups

Jason Calacanis covers startups, tech, markets, media, and all the hottest topics in business and technology. He also interviews the world’s greatest founders, operators, investors, and innovators.

View all episodes from This Week in Startups