Episode Summary
Executive Summary: Noah Smith discusses his Substack-driven workflow, Twitter’s influence and fragility, China’s slowing growth and political risks, and broader cyclical forces behind authoritarian and populist backlashes. He argues China’s era of catch-up growth is ending, Xi has mismanaged key policy areas, and global politics is seeing renewed fascist-style impulses, while the U.S. also faces elite overproduction and status frustration after the Great Recession.
Main Topics: Substack, blogging, and the creator economy (Priority: 4/5): Smith explains how Substack turned his former blogging work into a paid freelance career, and why he sees it as a relatively broad-based income platform rather than an extreme superstar economy. Twitter’s role in media and public discourse (Priority: 4/5): The conversation examines Twitter as a source of ideas, research, and distribution, while also questioning its toxicity and whether it can be replaced if it declines. China’s growth slowdown and political stability (Priority: 5/5): Smith argues China’s high-growth catch-up phase is over because of demographics, productivity convergence, and urbanization limits, making it harder for Xi Jinping to buy legitimacy through rising living standards. Xi Jinping’s record and China’s strategic errors (Priority: 5/5): Smith says Xi has been effective at consolidating CCP control but has repeatedly misstepped in the economy, foreign policy, and domestic governance through zero COVID, the real estate crackdown, Belt and Road, and repression in Hong Kong/Xinjiang. Fukuyama, liberalism, and recurring authoritarianism (Priority: 4/5): The discussion reframes the end-of-history thesis as a long-term upward trend in liberalism interrupted by recurring fascist or authoritarian cycles driven by status, dominance, and resentment. Elite overproduction, resentment, and U.S. social change (Priority: 5/5): Smith connects post-2008 stagnation and credential inflation to frustrated elites, rising populism, and new political movements, including wokism as a response to disrespect and structural exclusion.
Key Arguments: Substack offers a more sustainable long-tail creator economy than many other media platforms, allowing even niche writers to earn meaningful income. Twitter is useful for discovery and distribution, but it concentrates journalists, academics, and politicians in a toxic environment where they overreact to loud but unrepresentative voices. China’s rapid catch-up growth has ended because productivity convergence is exhausted, rural labor surplus is gone, and the population is aging rapidly. Xi Jinping cannot repeat Deng-era social bargains because China can no longer promise fast income growth; nationalism and state power are weaker substitutes for prosperity. Xi’s external and internal policies have often been self-defeating: Belt and Road produced backlash, Hong Kong/Xinjiang repression damaged China’s image, and zero COVID was maintained too long. The current wave of unrest in China may or may not culminate in a major political break; Smith is cautious and emphasizes he is not a China or security expert. Fukuyama’s thesis is best understood as a liberal upward trend with cyclical revivals of anti-liberal ideologies, especially fascism, whenever societies forget prior lessons. Authoritarian and fascist impulses recur because people seek dominance, status, and simplified national unity; modern variants appear in Russia, China, and parts of the American right. The U.S. has produced too many frustrated elites relative to available elite positions, especially after the Great Recession, intensifying resentment and political disruption. Wokism is interpreted as a recurring American reaction to deficits of respect, racial exclusion, workplace sexism, and policing abuses, not merely as an internet fad. Economic slowdowns can contribute to political unrest, but they are neither necessary nor sufficient; Japan’s lost decades and the unrest of the 1960s show multiple paths are possible.
Data Points: Substack elite earnings: over $1 million/year - Smith cites top politics writers on Substack as examples of the platform’s superstar tier. China GDP growth early 2010s: about 10% per year - Used to illustrate the high-growth phase that enabled the CCP’s legitimacy bargain. China GDP growth in the 2010s: about 6% per year - Shows the slowdown from peak catch-up growth during the decade. China youth population change: 18-29-year-olds have fallen by a large percent in recent years - Smith uses this to argue that demographics are a major headwind. China population peak/decline timing: population projected to begin decreasing next year - He links this to the end of demographic tailwinds. India population comparison: India will surpass China as the world’s most populous nation next year - Illustrates divergent demographic trajectories. China growth potential vs rich nations: ~4% vs ~2.5% - Smith says China could still outgrow rich countries, but not in a transformative catch-up way. Weibo views of protest/fire posts: more than 1.5 billion views - Referenced as evidence that information about the fire/protests spread widely despite censorship. Youth unemployment in China: roughly 20–30% - Smith uses this to describe severe labor market distress among young people. Non-Hispanic white share of U.S. population: about 60% - Used in the discussion of changing demographics and representation in the U.S. Non-Hispanic white share of young U.S. population: about 50% - Supports the point that younger generations are more diverse than older cohorts.
Pivotal Quotes: "Substack is the American dream." — Noah Smith: He describes how paid newsletter writing turned his hobby-blogging into a career. "Twitter is bad for our society because it basically shuts all the journalists, academics, and politicians in a small room with psychotic, pseudonymous teenagers." — Noah Smith: His critique of Twitter as a distorted feedback loop for elites and public opinion. "If this unrest reaches a large level, Xi Jinping doesn’t have the option of making the bargain that Deng and his successors struck." — Noah Smith: His core argument that China’s era of growth-for-legitimacy is over.
Implications: China faces rising political risk as growth slows and legitimacy shifts from prosperity to nationalism. In the U.S. and elsewhere, elite frustration and status conflict may keep fueling populism, wokism, and anti-liberal movements, even if liberal democracy retains the long-run advantage.
About Macro Musings
Hosted by David Beckworth of the Mercatus Center, Macro Musings pulls back the curtain on the important macroeconomic issues of the past, present, and future.