Episode Summary
Executive Summary: Michael Lewis revisits Liars Poker through a gender lens with Ann Clark Wolfe, asking whether Wall Street improved for women since the 1980s. Wolfe argues the culture was crude but more inclusive in some ways than today, when risk-averse norms, DEI outsourcing, and fear of cross-gender interactions can reduce mentorship and advancement.
Main Topics: Women on Wall Street then vs. now: The episode compares Solomon Brothers in the 1980s/early 1990s with modern Wall Street, debating whether women had better access, mentorship, and inclusion in the earlier era despite overt sexism. Liars Poker as cultural document: Lewis and Wolfe discuss how accurately the book captured Solomon Brothers’ floor culture, including the back-row/training-class dynamic and the way the book circulated internally as photocopied pages. Exclusion, mentorship, and sponsorship: Wolfe argues that women advanced when senior men treated them as part of the team and actively sponsored them, but that those personal relationships have weakened as interactions became more constrained. Fear, compliance, and the 'Pence rule': The conversation explores how concern about real or perceived impropriety can cause men to avoid one-on-one interactions with women, shrinking informal mentorship that often builds careers. Diversity as a business issue, not just a moral one: Wolfe frames underrepresentation as a market inefficiency: more diverse teams can produce better advice and financial results, yet incentives on Wall Street still don’t align with that logic. Creating Independence Point Advisors: Wolfe explains her new women- and minority-forward investment bank, built from her experience across major firms and her belief that cognitive diversity improves client outcomes.
Key Arguments: Solomon Brothers was sexist and crude, but women could sometimes advance there through talent, visibility, and direct sponsorship in a way that is harder now. Women often leave finance not because the work is merely long or hard, but because they experience exclusion and lack of inclusion. Modern Wall Street has more formal diversity structures, but these can let senior men opt out of real responsibility for developing women. Fear of accusations or discomfort around cross-gender relationships has reduced the informal settings where mentorship and trust often develop. Diversity should be viewed as a source of better decision-making and performance, not only as a social justice issue. Men’s overconfidence is rewarded in markets, but that same confidence may produce worse capital allocation than a more diverse, underconfident talent pool. Wall Street’s incentives have not sufficiently tied leaders’ compensation to retaining and advancing diverse talent. Women and minorities often survive Wall Street by being exceptional underdogs, which may translate into stronger advisory judgment and client empathy.
Data Points: Book circulation format: One mimeographed page at a time - Ann Clark Wolfe read Liars Poker during Solomon Brothers training in 1989 Training class timing: August 1989 - Wolfe joined Solomon after the 1987 crash, in a small hiring class Solomon tenure: 32 years - Wolfe describes her career across Solomon, Citigroup, JPMorgan, and Bank of America Large-firm experience: 3 biggest firms - Wolfe says she spent her career across Solomon, Citigroup, and Bank of America/JPMorgan roles Women-owned firm target: At least 70% women and people of color - Independence Point Advisors’ planned staffing composition White staffing cap: No more than 30% white - Wolfe’s stated goal for her new firm Working spouses at Solomon: At least 40% of men - Wolfe estimates the share of Solomon investment banking men with working spouses in 1990 Promotion timing: Six months pregnant - Wolfe says she was six months pregnant when promoted to managing director at Solomon Client performance claim: 12% better - Wolfe cites research/claims that diverse portfolio teams delivered better financial results Self-assessed insecurity: Four hours a day - Wolfe jokes she experiences imposter syndrome for much of the day Career at Bank of America: Almost 10 years - Part of Wolfe’s progression before founding Independence Point Advisors Career at JPMorgan: 2 years - Part of Wolfe’s progression before founding Independence Point Advisors Headcount rule referenced: 70% / 30% - Staffing mix target for the new firm
Pivotal Quotes: "I think it's actually far worse today than it was in 1990 because in 1990 it truly was just about capitalism." — Ann Clark Wolfe: Wolfe explains why she believes modern Wall Street can be less inclusive than the Solomon era "The conditions where a young woman would build a professional relationship with an older, important man happen to be the same conditions where the older man might suggest an inappropriate relationship." — Michael Lewis: Lewis summarizes the dilemma around mentorship and fear of impropriety "I'm the DEI officer." — A former Solomon boss (as recounted by Ann Clark Wolfe): Used to argue that senior executives should personally own diversity responsibility rather than outsourcing it
Implications: The episode argues that improving women’s outcomes on Wall Street requires more than formal DEI programs: senior leaders must sponsor talent, create real access, and align incentives with retention. Otherwise, fear and bureaucracy may keep the industry less diverse and less efficient.
About Against the Rules
Michael Lewis’s best-selling book The Big Short is now 15 years old. The Oscar-winning movie based on it came out a decade ago. To mark the occasion, Lewis has narrated a new audiobook of The Big Short. Here on his podcast, he and co-host Lidia Jean Kott are thinking about the legacy of the book, the movie, and the financial crisis of 2008. Michael catches up with the director of the movie, Adam McKay, as well as some of the real-life characters depicted by the likes of Ryan Gosling, Steve Carell and Jeremy Strong. He also calls up journalists, economists, and historians to make sense of the 2008 financial crisis and to understand how it still affects the world today.