Bankless
Bankless

Should I Buy ETH Treasuries? Early Stage Greed Cycle? | Michael Nadeau’s DeFi Report #4

Public companies are racing to lock ETH onto their balance sheets, but is this the spark for a late-cycle greed run or a setup for a painful reversal? Mike Nadeau from The DeFi Report joins Ryan to unpack the ETH treasury boom, explain how staking yield and convertible debt amplify reflexivity, and

Featured Speakers

Mike Nado Guest

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode argues that crypto is in a late-cycle but still-bullish phase, with ETH treasury companies emerging as a major new market structure. Mike Nado explains why ETH may be superior to BTC for treasury strategies due to staking yield and higher volatility, while warning investors about dilution, premium-to-NAV risks, and eventual reflexive downside. He also outlines on-chain signs of early greed/altseason.

Main Topics: Cycle Positioning: Late Bull but Still Bullish (Priority: 5/5): The hosts frame the market as year three of a bull cycle—typically the strongest phase but nearing late-stage conditions. They see recent dips as normal and think greed is replacing fear, though not yet full euphoria. ETH Treasury Companies as a New Market Meta (Priority: 5/5): A major segment of the discussion is the rise of public ETH treasury vehicles, including Bitmine, SharpLink, Bit Digital, and others. These entities are compared to Bitcoin treasury companies but with key structural advantages and risks. Why ETH May Be Better Than BTC for Treasury Strategies (Priority: 5/5): Mike argues ETH is superior for treasury companies because it offers staking yield and has higher volatility, which makes convertibles more valuable and can improve capital-raising terms. Premiums, Reflexivity, and MNAV (Priority: 4/5): The episode explains why treasury companies trade above NAV: attention, access to capital, leverage, and reflexive feedback loops. The same mechanics can also unwind if sentiment reverses or dilution accelerates. DeFi Yield as the Second-Order Trade (Priority: 4/5): If ETH treasury firms deploy capital on-chain, it could increase TVL, fees, lending activity, and demand for DeFi yield. The hosts suggest blue-chip protocols may benefit first, especially those adjacent to staking and lower-risk yield. Signals of Greed and Altseason (Priority: 5/5): On-chain and macro indicators—liquidity, active loans, stablecoin supply, BTC long-term holder behavior, ETH futures OI, and altcoin season metrics—suggest the market is entering early greed/rotation rather than peak mania. Portfolio Rotation and Risk Management (Priority: 4/5): Mike says he is reducing BTC weight and increasing exposure to ETH and select public market beta plays, but stresses most investors should still own mostly ETH rather than overcomplicate with treasury-stock selection.

Key Arguments: ETH treasury companies can become powerful reflexive vehicles because they combine public-market access, attention, and on-chain capital deployment. ETH is better suited than BTC for treasury strategies because staking can grow ETH-per-share and ETH's higher volatility improves convertibility and financing optionality. The premium to NAV exists because these stocks are not just asset wrappers; they are attention-driven, levered, and easier to buy in brokerage accounts than spot crypto. DeFi may benefit as treasury companies move ETH into staking, lending, and other yield strategies, increasing fees, TVL, and transaction activity. The market is in a late but not terminal phase of the bull cycle; greed is rising, but the strongest euphoria likely has not arrived yet. Investors should be cautious about dilution, capital-structure complexity, and the possibility that smaller treasury companies end up in a doom loop if premiums collapse. The biggest winners among ETH treasury companies will likely be those that move fastest, communicate best, and earn the market's trust. For most investors, directly owning ETH is still the cleaner expression of the thesis; treasury companies are higher-beta trade vehicles, not core holdings.

Data Points: ETH vs all-time high: ~25% below ATH - Used to show ETH still has upside even after strong performance. Bull market year: Year 3 - Hosts describe the crypto cycle as being in the strongest but later stage. BTC treasury premium (MNAV): ~1.7x - MicroStrategy/Strategy discussed as trading at a premium to NAV. MicroStrategy peak MNAV: 3.89x - Reported as the high premium reached in November of last year. MicroStrategy vs BTC performance: ~15x vs ~6-7x since start of 2023 bull market - Illustrates the power of the treasury-company structure. ETH annualized volatility: 59% - Compared with Bitcoin to argue ETH is more volatile and more valuable for convertible financing. BTC annualized volatility: ~40% - Used as the comparison point for ETH's higher vol. ETH treasury company share of supply: ~1% of ETH locked in public treasury vehicles - Indicates the scale of treasury-company demand relative to total supply. Tom Lee company holdings: 833,000 ETH - Bitmine Immersion Technologies holdings as of Aug. 4. Tom Lee purchase plan: 5% of total ETH supply - Stated target for ETH accumulation. Bitmine added purchase: 200,000 ETH - Mentioned as an additional buy on Aug. 3/4. Bit Digital holdings: Over 100,000 ETH - Bit Digital described as a major ETH treasury company after pivoting from BTC mining. Bit Digital raise: $172 million - Capital raised and deployed into ETH holdings. Bitmine assets: ~$3 billion AUM - Approximate size of Tom Lee's ETH treasury company. Treasury company ranking: Top 3 crypto treasury company; top 3-5 ETH treasury company - Describes Bitmine/Bit Digital positioning in the sector. Active loans on DeFi protocols: All-time highs - Aave, Morpho, Spark, Fluid, Euler are cited as showing strong leverage demand. Tether supply growth: +11% over 90 days - Used as a bullish liquidity signal for crypto. US deficit: Over $1.3 trillion in first nine months of fiscal year - Macro liquidity support via Treasury spending. Budget deficit target: Up to 7% - Big Beautiful Bill discussed as increasing deficits. BTC long-term holder supply change: -1.3% over a few weeks - Shows early distribution from long-term holders. Stablecoin supply: At all-time highs - Supportive of future crypto demand and liquidity. Degen vs non-degen DEX metric: New Solana metric introduced - Used to detect the return of animal spirits on-chain.

Pivotal Quotes: "We are in year three of a bull market cycle. These tend to be the biggest years, and we're moving towards the end of that." — Mike Nado: Explaining why the market is late-stage but still structurally bullish. "To me, this is all about attention as kind of the first element of this." — Mike Nado: Describing why MicroStrategy trades at a premium to NAV and how that applies to ETH treasury companies. "ETH is actually a higher vol asset... and you potentially have a situation where... this is potentially going to create competition for him within these convertible debt markets as well." — Mike Nado: Arguing ETH's volatility and yield make it stronger than BTC for treasury strategies.

Implications: Crypto may be rotating into an ETH-led greed phase, with public treasury vehicles amplifying both upside and downside. DeFi blue chips, ETH, and select treasury stocks may benefit first, but dilution and reflexivity create major risks.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Bankless

View all episodes from Bankless