Bankless
Bankless

Why Banks Suck, The Great Taking & How To Prepare | Mel Mattison

Why do banks suck? Banks suck is the reason we started this bankless thing. Not that banks are all bad but they take too much and give to little. They need to be disrupted. We brought Mel Mattison, author of Quoz, and he’s very clear on what’s wrong with banks. They’ve become too centralized, unbala

Featured Speakers

Mel Madison Guest

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode argues that modern banking and central banking evolved into a centralized, politically connected system that taxes citizens through money creation, supports state power, and concentrates wealth. Mel Madison traces this history from the Bank of England to the BIS, warns of debt-driven instability and a possible monetary reset, and urges listeners to prefer scarce, self-custodied assets like Bitcoin, gold, and silver.

Main Topics: Why banks “suck” and how they became centralized (Priority: 5/5): Mel Madison frames banks as institutions that originally served useful private-market functions but became dangerous once they fused with state power, enabling coercion, money creation, and wealth extraction from the public. Historical roots of central banking and money power (Priority: 5/5): The conversation traces monetary control from Hamilton, the Bank of England, the gold/silver debates, the Crime of 1873, and the Federal Reserve’s creation, arguing that monetary policy has always been political and distributive. The BIS and global central bank coordination (Priority: 5/5): Madison describes the Bank for International Settlements as a shadowy coordination hub where major central bankers align policy, set agendas, and influence global monetary direction outside public scrutiny. Inflation, debt, and financial repression (Priority: 5/5): The discussion emphasizes that inflation functions as a hidden tax, while rising debt and interest expense create pressure for repression, rate suppression, and continued debasement rather than structural reform. The Great Taking and property-rights risk (Priority: 4/5): Madison explains David Rogers Webb’s thesis that modern securities ownership may be vulnerable in a systemic crisis because intermediated holdings and legal structures could subordinate investors’ claims. How to prepare: liquidity, hard assets, and crypto (Priority: 5/5): The practical takeaway is to stay liquid, avoid long-duration bonds, own scarce assets, and prefer self-custodied Bitcoin and precious metals over intermediated financial products.

Key Arguments: Central banking is fundamentally an alliance between governments and private financial elites, created to fund state spending and war without visible taxation. Money creation functions as an inflation tax that quietly transfers wealth from savers and wage earners to debtors, banks, and governments. The BIS provides the real venue for global central bank coordination, making monetary policy more synchronized and less transparent than most people realize. The Federal Reserve is not purely public; it is part of a system with private ownership and bank shareholders in the regional reserve banks. The Great Depression does not prove central banks are necessary; Madison argues debt relief and monetary adjustment could have been done without a central bank. The current system encourages debt accumulation, wealth concentration, and eventual instability, making a broad monetary reset likely. Bitcoin and precious metals are favored because they are scarce, harder to debase, and more resistant to intermediated seizure than legacy financial assets. Self-custody matters because exchange-held or ETF-held crypto is not the same as directly holding bearer assets. A reform path exists: phase out the central bank, issue non-interest-bearing Treasury money, and reduce bank privilege without immediate collapse. Short-term coordination by central banks may calm markets, but over time it delays necessary adjustment and worsens systemic fragility.

Data Points: BIS central bank gathering frequency: Every 2 months - Madison says the top central bank chiefs meet regularly in Basel at the Bank for International Settlements. Number of central banks involved in BIS meetings: Top 63 central banks - He claims the BIS hosts the heads of the major central banks globally, with Russia excluded after the Ukraine invasion. Historical establishment of the Bank of England: 1694 - Madison identifies the Bank of England as the prototype modern central bank. First U.S. paper money during the Revolution: $2 million initially - He references the Continental Congress’s early fiat issuance to fund the Revolutionary War. Peak Revolutionary War fiat issuance: Over $160 million - He says Continental currency was massively expanded and later devalued. Redemption value of Continental currency: 1 continental to 1 penny - Used as an example of fiat collapse and debasement. Coinage Act controversy: 1873 - Madison cites the Coinage Act of 1873, dubbed the Crime of 73, as removing silver from the monetary system. Free silver political flashpoint: 1896 - He references William Jennings Bryan’s “cross of gold” speech. Federal Reserve creation: 1913 - He notes the Fed and the federal income tax both emerged in 1913. Gold revaluation under FDR: $20/oz to $35/oz - Used to argue monetary relief during the Depression did not require a central bank. Financial crisis reserve interest policy: Post-2008 - He says the Fed began paying interest on reserves after the financial crisis. Gold holdings claimed by China: Around 2,000+ metric tons - Madison cites official Chinese reserve disclosures. Speculated Chinese gold holdings: Over 30,000 metric tons - He relays the view of some observers that China may hold far more gold than reported. U.S. gold reserves: Around 8,000 metric tons - Madison contrasts U.S. reported gold holdings with China’s reported and rumored holdings. Real wages as share of GDP: Cut in half since 1971 - He uses this to argue that post-gold-standard financialization worsened distributional outcomes. U.S. debt-to-GDP level: Over 120% - He says current levels are surpassing World War II-era peaks. World War II debt reduction inflation: About 40% cumulative inflation in 1946-47 - He cites postwar inflation as the previous method of reducing debt burdens. Interest expense increase: Almost 50% year-over-year - He claims federal interest costs have surged due to refinancing at higher rates. Treasury refinancing scale: $10+ trillion - He says this amount of existing debt needs rollover at higher rates. Treasury market signal distortion: 200 basis points - He argues the yield curve is distorted and compares front-end rates with mortgage-backed security yields. Potential Social Security Trust Fund stress: 2027-2028 - He says this window could intensify fiscal and political pressure. S&P 500 outlook mentioned: 6,000 by end of year; 7,000 by next year - Madison gives a bullish near-term market forecast despite long-term concerns. Bitcoin exposure timing: First heard in 2012; bought about 5-6 years later - He recounts missing an early opportunity to buy Bitcoin. Silver bar cost basis: About $10/oz - He says a silver bar he bought then is now worth far more.

Pivotal Quotes: "banking establishments are more dangerous than standing armies" — Thomas Jefferson: Cited to frame the episode’s thesis that banks can be more threatening than military power because they control money and taxation. "So all these global central bankers, they get together at the Bank for International Settlements in Basel and they decide exactly what they want to be doing." — Ryan Sean Adams: Opening framing of the BIS as a coordinating center for global monetary policy. "the real issue is the control of money in private hands and in the banking cartel" — Mel Madison: Madison’s core claim about why central banking is harmful and why reform should target money power itself.

Implications: Listeners are urged to expect continued monetary instability, rising debt pressure, and more visible coordination among central banks. The practical response is to stay liquid, avoid long-duration bonds, and favor scarce, self-custodied assets like Bitcoin and precious metals.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Bankless

View all episodes from Bankless