Intelligence Squared
Intelligence Squared

Yuval Noah Harari on the myths we need to survive

Myths. We tend to think they’re a thing of the past, fabrications that early humans needed to believe in because their understanding of the world was so meagre. But what if modern civilisation were itself based on a set of myths? This is the big question posed by Professor Yuval Noah Harari, author

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The podcast centers on Yuval Noah Harari’s thesis that human history is driven by three revolutions—cognitive, agricultural, and scientific—and that shared myths such as religion, money, nationalism, and consumerism make large-scale societies possible. He argues these fictions unify people but also justify hierarchy, conflict, and ecological damage, while science increasingly gives humans “godlike” power without moral direction.

Main Topics: The three revolutions shaping human history (Priority: 5/5): Harari frames history as beginning with the cognitive revolution, followed by agriculture and then science, each dramatically increasing human power and reshaping society. Myths, fictions, and social cooperation (Priority: 5/5): The conversation explores how shared stories—religion, money, human rights, nationalism—allow millions of strangers to cooperate, but also divide communities and shift rapidly over time. Hierarchy, elites, and gender inequality (Priority: 4/5): Harari explains how social hierarchies become stable through legitimizing stories rather than mere accidents of power, and discusses why male dominance has persisted across societies. Money, capitalism, and consumerism (Priority: 5/5): Money is presented as the most successful shared fiction ever told, with capitalism sustained by trust in growth and the belief that buying more solves personal problems. Science, technology, and future religions (Priority: 5/5): Harari argues that future ideologies and religions are likely to emerge from Silicon Valley or Bangalore, as biotechnology and AI transform bodies, brains, work, and identity. Climate change and the limits of current political systems (Priority: 4/5): He warns that climate change is being overwhelmed by the capitalist growth narrative and that current nation-states are too small a scale to solve global problems. The role of science versus ideology (Priority: 4/5): Harari argues science is not self-sufficient because it cannot answer ethical questions; it provides power, while religion or ideology decides how that power is used.

Key Arguments: Human history only truly begins with the cognitive revolution, when Homo sapiens developed language and the ability to create and spread fictions. Humans rose to the top of the food chain too quickly for ecosystems or societies to adapt, contributing to extinctions and ongoing ecological disruption. Large societies depend on shared myths because people cannot know everyone personally once communities become too large. Most successful myths are believed sincerely by their promoters, not cynically invented as pure manipulation. Social hierarchies become durable only when accidental power differences are turned into legitimizing stories, such as divine origin or racial superiority. Gender inequality is one of history’s deepest puzzles; physical strength alone cannot explain it, and the answer may lie in large-scale social organization and myth-based hierarchies. Money works because it is a collectively trusted fiction backed by confidence in institutions and the capitalist system. Economic growth is capitalism’s master story, and consumerism translates that story into the personal belief that every problem can be solved by buying something. Future major religions are more likely to be techno-religions than traditional faiths because biotechnology and AI will create new human needs and anxieties. Science produces power, not moral purpose; therefore it must be paired with an ideology or religion to decide how it should be used. Nationalism is weakening because the major problems of the 21st century—climate change, AI, globalization—are global rather than national. Climate action is constrained because reducing emissions currently conflicts with economic growth, and governments are unwilling to sacrifice growth.

Data Points: Start of cognitive revolution: about 70,000 years ago - Harari dates the beginning of history to the cognitive revolution Agricultural revolution: about 10,000 years ago - The second major revolution that accelerated historical development Scientific revolution: about 500 years ago - The third revolution, still in its early stages Human origins before the cognitive revolution: about 2.5 million years - Harari notes humans existed long before becoming ecologically dominant Australia extinctions after sapiens arrival: more than 90% of big animals extinct - Within a few thousand years after humans reached Australia about 45,000–50,000 years ago America extinctions after sapiens arrival: more than 70% of big mammals extinct - Within roughly 2,000 years after humans crossed into the Americas about 15,000 years ago Big animals on Earth today: more than 90% are humans or domesticated animals - Harari uses this to illustrate human domination of the biosphere Federal Reserve money creation: 3 billion dollars per day - At the height of the economic crisis, as described in the discussion Total money created in that year: 1 trillion dollars - Harari cites this as evidence that money is fundamentally trust-based and electronic Estimated timeline for AI replacing humans in jobs: 30–40 years - Used to illustrate why future ideologies must address technological disruption Taiping Rebellion death toll: 20 million deaths - Harari presents it as the biggest war of the 19th century Taiping Rebellion duration: 14 years - Historical example of fundamentalist reaction to industrial change First World War Italian deaths: about 650,000 killed - Used in a comparison to declining nationalism First World War Italian injuries: more than 1 million injured - Illustrates the earlier intensity of nationalist commitment

Pivotal Quotes: "Humankind are now in the process of acquiring divine abilities through scientific research and technological development." — Yuval Noah Harari: On the scientific revolution and humanity’s growing power to redesign life "Homo sapiens is basically a bunch of sheep that got nuclear weapons and atomic power." — Yuval Noah Harari: On the dangers of insecure humans acquiring immense technological power too quickly "Science provides the power, religion tells us what to do with it." — Yuval Noah Harari: On why science and ideology must be allied to guide technological progress

Implications: Listeners are left with a warning: technology is advancing faster than our moral frameworks. The future will likely depend on new global narratives that can guide AI, biotech, climate policy, and identity beyond nationalism and old religions.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Intelligence Squared

View all episodes from Intelligence Squared