Accidental Tech Podcast
Accidental Tech Podcast

225: A Conversation with Siri

Our WWDC 2017 live show! Sponsored by: * Squarespace: Build it beautiful. Use code ATP for 10% off your first order. * Audible.com: With Audible, you’ll find what you’re looking for. Get a free 30-day trial. * Fracture: Photos printed in vivid color directly on glass. Get 10% of your first order.

Featured Speakers

Marco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode is a live ATP reaction to Apple’s WWDC keynote, with the hosts weighing the biggest announcements across macOS, iOS 11, iPad Pro, hardware updates, and the surprise HomePod. They broadly praise the breadth of updates—especially iPad productivity, the iMac Pro, and system-level improvements—while questioning naming, Siri’s limitations, 32-bit app sunset, and the incomplete story around new products shipping later in the year.

Main Topics: WWDC keynote pacing and structure: The hosts note that the keynote moved unusually fast and covered a large amount of material, forcing them to process announcements in keynote order and react in real time to many items that were not yet shipping. macOS High Sierra and desktop platform changes: Discussion centers on APFS, Safari tracking prevention, Metal graphics investment, and concern over 32-bit app deprecation. The hosts see High Sierra as an incremental release but important technically. iOS 11 and iPad productivity overhaul: The strongest enthusiasm is for iPad changes: drag and drop, multitasking, Files-like workflows, a redesigned Control Center, and a more desktop-like interaction model that makes the iPad feel like a serious productivity device. New hardware: iMac, iMac Pro, and updated MacBooks: They react positively to the refreshed iMac line, the space gray iMac Pro, and routine MacBook updates on a healthier cadence. The iMac Pro is viewed as a temporary answer to Mac Pro needs while preserving room for a future modular Mac Pro. HomePod and Siri’s limitations: The HomePod is seen as a promising high-end music speaker competing with Sonos, but the hosts worry Apple underplayed Siri and that the product lacks a clear screen, developer story, or strong smart-assistant demonstration. iCloud, Messages, Photos, and ecosystem syncing: They highlight improvements in Messages syncing, Photos metadata syncing, family storage plans, and HEIF/HEVC adoption as practical ecosystem wins, though some features are framed as catching up to long-standing user expectations. App Store redesign and new developer surfaces: The new App Store app is discussed as a major UI change with separate games/apps tabs, richer product pages, and visible in-app purchases, but the hosts reserve judgment on whether discovery and search will truly improve.

Key Arguments: The keynote was unusually dense and fast, but Apple chose to show many future products early rather than wait for separate events. High Sierra is mostly incremental, but APFS, Safari anti-tracking, and Metal make it technically significant. 32-bit Mac app support is nearing its end, and Apple is signaling that developers must move to 64-bit. The iPad is now being pushed much closer to Mac-like productivity, with drag-and-drop and multitasking as major steps forward. The iMac Pro effectively fills the high-end Mac gap temporarily, but a true Mac Pro still needs expandability and better serviceability. HomePod looks like a premium speaker first and a smart speaker second, which may be the right positioning against Sonos but leaves Siri underexplained. Messages sync across devices and richer iCloud integration could be one of the most practically important updates if implemented cleanly. The new App Store could significantly change discovery and monetization, especially by exposing in-app purchases more clearly.

Data Points: HomePod price: $349 - Used as a premium price point when comparing the product to Sonos and smart speakers like Amazon Echo. iMac Pro starting price: $5,000 - Mentioned as the entry cost for the pro-grade all-in-one Mac. iMac Pro CPU ceiling: 18-core Xeon - Highlighted as evidence the iMac Pro is effectively Mac Pro-class hardware in an iMac case. iMac Pro memory ceiling: 128 GB ECC RAM - Discussed as part of the machine’s workstation-class positioning. MacBook Air update: 1 MHz bump (described jokingly as minimal) - A humorous way of saying the MacBook Air update was extremely minor. iPad Pro refresh rate: 120 Hz - Discussed as a major display and latency improvement on the new iPad Pro. iPad Pro latency: 20 ms - Referenced as the response latency Apple touted while discussing the new display experience. Apple keynote timing: A few hours after WWDC keynote - The episode was recorded live shortly after Apple’s opening keynote at WWDC. Subscription trial length: 30 days - Mentioned in the Audible sponsor spot. Discount code: 10% off - Squarespace and Fracture sponsor offers included a 10% discount. Audience participation: Most attendees knew what happened after the theme song - Used as a live-show format check before the hosts improvised the episode structure.

Pivotal Quotes: "“This is the big and best WWDC ever.”" — Tim Cook (referenced by hosts): The hosts debate whether Apple’s keynote lived up to the CEO’s framing of the event. "“What happens after that?”" — Marco: A pre-show format question about what the live recording should do after the theme song plays. "“It turns out desktop operating systems had a bunch of good ideas after all, didn't they?”" — Marco: A reaction to iPad productivity features like drag and drop and multitasking becoming more Mac-like.

Implications: Apple is moving toward a more mature, productivity-focused ecosystem: iPad becomes more capable, Mac hardware gets a clearer roadmap, and privacy/system features tighten. But Siri, naming, and delayed shipping keep expectations cautious.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Accidental Tech Podcast

View all episodes from Accidental Tech Podcast