Accidental Tech Podcast
Accidental Tech Podcast

577: Colorful Criticism

* Pre-show: Old men talk about old car stereos * Follow-up: * John’s notes export via privacy.apple.com * Apple Vision Pro & Project Titan (via James Anthony) * JIBO * gita (the robot Casey was thinking of) * Gurman’s article (or on Apple News) * Apple Vision Pro’s inevitable future (via Matt Jo

Featured Speakers

Marco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode moves from a humorous tween slang tangent to deep dives on Apple’s product and policy battles: Vision Pro’s long-term glasses future, the M3 MacBook Air’s new dual-external-display support, and Apple’s escalating legal conflict with the EU, Spotify, and Epic over App Store anti-steering rules and DMA compliance. The hosts argue Apple’s platform power is real but increasingly constrained by regulation and developer backlash.

Main Topics: Tween slang and the ‘aux’ music request: The hosts open with a family anecdote about a son wanting to play his music through the speakers, leading to a comedic investigation of the slang phrase 'put me on aux' and its origins in older auxiliary input jacks. Vision Pro’s product roadmap and the glasses debate: They debate whether Vision Pro is a stepping stone toward glasses-style AR or whether the headset and future glasses are fundamentally different product lines. They argue the headset enables immersive use cases glasses cannot, while glasses would solve pass-through and bulk problems but require major hardware compromises. M3 MacBook Air and external display support: The hosts discuss the surprise release of the M3 MacBook Air and the practical improvement of supporting two external displays when the lid is closed. They note Apple later promised the same for the 14-inch M3 MacBook Pro and question whether Apple will backport the feature to M2 models. Apple Notes export limitations: A discussion of exporting Apple Notes reveals that Apple’s export is incomplete: it produces plain text files and separate images, but loses rich formatting, link fidelity, image placement, cropping, and other styling, making it a backup rather than a faithful archive. Apple vs. EU: App Store antitrust fine and anti-steering: A major segment analyzes the EU’s roughly €1.84 billion fine against Apple for App Store music-streaming restrictions and anti-steering rules. The hosts frame the dispute as a clash between U.S.-style monopoly law and the EU’s broader competition philosophy, then critique Apple’s combative public response. Epic, third-party marketplaces, and Apple’s trust issues: The hosts examine Apple’s termination of Epic’s new Sweden-based developer account after tense email exchanges. They view it as a personal and strategic clash: Apple says Epic is ‘verifiably untrustworthy,’ while Epic accuses Apple of bad-faith compliance. The segment also covers AltStore gaining marketplace approval.

Key Arguments: 'Put me on aux' is modern slang rooted in the old auxiliary audio input, meaning the listener wants control of the music source. Vision Pro’s strongest current use cases are immersive ones; clear AR glasses would solve some problems but create entirely different engineering constraints. A glasses-based Vision Pro cannot simply be a smaller headset; it would require a very different power, camera, and display architecture. Apple’s Notes export is not a true backup because it strips rich text, formatting, link behavior, and image layout. The M3 MacBook Air’s dual-external-display support is a meaningful practical upgrade, and Apple likely enabled it via firmware because the M2 platform already had the capability. The EU treats Apple as a gatekeeper in a low-competition market and is trying to restore consumer choice through regulation. Apple’s response to the EU fine is defensive and emotionally loaded, portraying itself as a platform provider that already gives developers significant value. Spotify’s free tier and Apple’s selective treatment of Spotify weaken Apple’s claim that the App Store is a fully level playing field. Apple’s reader-app exception is the clearest workaround to anti-steering rules, but its restrictions are so tight that it still functions as a barrier. Epic’s ban from a new developer account shows that Apple will use trust, history, and discretion to exclude adversarial partners even while claiming compliance. The DMA’s success is uncertain because Apple can comply in technically narrow ways that preserve control and limit real competition. A better Apple strategy would be to lower its economic dependence on App Store coercion and compete on product quality rather than restrictions.

Data Points: EU fine against Apple: €1.84 billion (about $2 billion) - Penalty announced for App Store music-streaming anti-steering practices Spotify share mentioned in Apple’s response: 56% of Europe’s music streaming market - Apple cites this to argue Spotify is thriving and not harmed Apple’s review volume for Spotify: 421 app versions reviewed - Apple says its app review team has processed Spotify submissions, often same-day M3 MacBook Air external displays: Up to 2 external displays when lid is closed - New capability highlighted in the release M3 MacBook Air external display limit: 1 external display up to 6K at 60Hz when open - Apple’s documented spec M3 MacBook Air memory ceiling: Up to 24GB unified memory - Part of the product announcement M3 MacBook Air storage ceiling: Up to 2TB SSD - Part of the product announcement Wi‑Fi standard change: Wi‑Fi 6 to Wi‑Fi 6E - Connectivity update in the M3 MacBook Air Recycled content: 50% recycled content overall - Apple’s environmental claim for the new MacBook Air Recycled aluminum: 100% recycled aluminum - Used in the enclosure Recycled rare earth elements: 100% recycled rare earth elements - Used in all magnets Recycled copper: 100% recycled copper - Used in the main logic board Packaging: 99% fiber-based - Apple’s packaging/environmental statement Apple Notes export size: 337 megabytes - Export described as a large but lossy archive Vision Pro purchase price referenced: $3,500 - Used repeatedly as a benchmark for the headset category EU/Apple marketplace requirement discussed: 1 million euros or equivalent letter of credit - Apple’s initial condition for third-party marketplace approval EU alternative marketplace threshold mentioned later: 1 million first annual installs in the EU or 2 years in good standing - Updated Apple requirement for some marketplace eligibility paths App Store revenue share referenced from prior court case: 87% of in-app purchase tax revenue from games - Used to argue Apple could loosen rules for non-game apps while preserving revenue

Pivotal Quotes: "Put me on aux." — Chat / youth slang reference: The phrase the hosts identify as modern slang for taking over the speakers/music source "This decision sent a powerful message. No company, not even a monopoly like Apple, can wield power abusively to control how other companies interact with their customers." — The Verge summary quoted in the discussion: Used to frame the EU fine and Apple’s App Store conduct "History shows, however, that Epic is verifiably untrustworthy." — Apple / Phil Schiller email excerpt: Apple’s justification for terminating Epic’s new Sweden-based developer account

Implications: Apple’s control over platform rules is under sustained regulatory and reputational pressure. The EU may keep forcing changes, but Apple can still shape compliance in ways that preserve power. Developers and competitors should expect years of friction, partial concessions, and strategic battles over marketplace access.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Accidental Tech Podcast

View all episodes from Accidental Tech Podcast