Accidental Tech Podcast
Accidental Tech Podcast

592: I Think He Won the Game

* Pre-show: Marco’s nethers and the Vision Pro * The Talk Show Live from WWDC 2024 * Theatre (App Store link) * Sandwich * SpatialGen * ATP Interview: Holly Borla & Ben Cohen * Microsoft Recall * 7 June: Microsoft Recall will be opt-in * 13 June: Microsoft Recalls Recall * Microsoft blog post *

Featured Speakers

Marco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode centers on WWDC follow-up: the Vision Pro proves genuinely useful for couch-bound computing and live 3D event viewing, while Apple’s software/platform changes are mixed—Sequoia, iOS 18, VisionOS 2, and CarPlay add useful features, but Apple Intelligence raises RAM and reliability concerns. The hosts also critique Microsoft’s Recall rollout, Apple’s App Store/DMA posture, and major policy shifts around Swift, testing, HomeKit, and third-party app support.

Main Topics: Vision Pro as a couch-bound computing tool: One host’s vasectomy recovery created an ideal Vision Pro use case: hands-free viewing on a couch, with the headset providing a straight-ahead virtual display while lying down. They compare it to the iPad’s famous hospital-bed usefulness and note Vision Pro’s limitations for general-purpose work but real value for passive or low-motion computing. WWDC live 3D broadcast and event viewing: They praise the live 3D broadcast of The Talk Show Live via Sandwich/Theater as a standout technical achievement and a glimpse of future spatial video event viewing for concerts, sports, and productions. The hosts note Apple itself has not yet shipped similar live event coverage. Apple Intelligence, RAM, and product strategy: The discussion repeatedly returns to Apple Intelligence: its hardware requirements, Apple’s public framing, model training on web data, and concerns about hallucinations, privacy, and the burden of rolling out AI features across Apple’s ecosystem. The hosts argue Apple’s longstanding RAM stinginess is now colliding with AI demands. Platform and policy friction: Apple, Microsoft, and the EU: Microsoft’s Recall feature is criticized for being rushed, then forced to become opt-in and delayed; Apple’s DMA compliance is expected to draw EU charges; and UTM’s rejection from both App Store and third-party notarization is viewed as a troubling sign of Apple’s gatekeeping. OS feature follow-up: macOS Sequoia, iOS 18, VisionOS 2, CarPlay: The hosts review a broad range of small but meaningful OS updates: Sidecar handwriting, iPhone mirroring, network locations returning, password app quirks, window tiling tweaks, iCloud in macOS VMs, iOS flashlight/side-button changes, locked camera extensions, VisionOS guest improvements, and CarPlay enhancements. Swift ecosystem maturation and testing: Swift is moving from Apple’s GitHub org to a dedicated SwiftLang organization, signaling broader independence and maturity. They also highlight Swift Testing as the future-forward replacement for older testing patterns. Personal anecdote: the $20,000 pebble: The episode ends with an extended, dramatic story about a Volvo engine failure caused by an improbably wedged pebble that destroyed the serpentine belt, timing belt, and engine. The story becomes a metaphor for absurd bad luck and the practical realities of insurance and repair costs.

Key Arguments: Vision Pro becomes meaningfully useful when a user is immobilized; lying down with a virtual screen is a real, if narrow, productivity/watching win. Live stereoscopic broadcasts can make spatial video compelling; even a fixed-camera 3D stream can feel like being there and should be expanded to sports and concerts. Apple Intelligence’s biggest constraint is RAM, not just CPU/NPU capability; Apple’s historical under-provisioning now limits which devices can run the new features. Apple’s AI training posture is more conservative than some competitors, but still uncomfortable because it includes web-crawled public data and opt-out mechanisms that arrive too late for many publishers. Microsoft’s Recall was predictably headed for backlash because of its default behavior and security implications; changing it after launch damage was inevitable. Apple’s DMA compliance appears designed to preserve Apple’s advantage rather than enable genuine competition, which increases the likelihood of EU penalties. UTM’s rejection suggests Apple may be using policy interpretation to block apps it simply doesn’t want, even in third-party stores where the stated review scope is narrower. Several WWDC platform updates are practical and welcome, but many remain deeply hidden or unevenly implemented, such as HomeKit hub selection, flashlight controls, and iPhone mirroring. Swift moving to its own GitHub org is both symbolic and practical: Apple is signaling it wants Swift to be taken seriously as a general-purpose language beyond Apple platforms. The CarPlay and VisionOS additions show Apple is still iterating, but some features reflect a services-first mindset that can intrude on user experience, especially in full-screen media contexts.

Data Points: Vision Pro use case duration: 1–2+ months unused before re-setup - The headset had been sitting unused in its case for a month or two before being set up again for couch recovery use. Talk Show Live runtime: 2 hours - The live WWDC show ran significantly longer than expected. Microsoft Recall default status: Opt-in - Microsoft changed Recall to be off by default after backlash. Recall delay timing: June 13, 2024 - Microsoft delayed Recall again and moved it to Windows Insider preview. Copilot Plus PC feature availability: Not guaranteed at launch for Intel/AMD - Intel Lunar Lake and AMD Strix Point laptops may require later software updates for AI features. App Store review period for UTMSE: Almost 2 months - UTM reported Apple’s review process took nearly two months before rejection. Apple DMA penalty exposure: Up to 5% of annual revenue - The EU penalties discussed could be extremely large if levied at the reported scale. Move streak: 3,338 days - A listener’s Apple Watch streak began on April 24, 2015, the original Apple Watch launch day. Apple Watch launch date used in calculation: April 23, 2015 / day-one retail context - The conversation ties the move streak to the original Apple Watch release window. Volvo model year: 2017 XC90 - The car that suffered the catastrophic engine failure was a 2017 Volvo XC90. Vehicle mileage: ~40,000–45,000 miles - The Volvo had relatively low mileage and had been maintained regularly. Repair labor estimate: 25–30 hours at $175/hour - The engine replacement estimate included substantial labor costs. Parts estimate for engine replacement: Over $14,000 - The parts alone for a new engine were quoted at more than fourteen thousand dollars. Total repair estimate: Around $20,000 - New engine plus labor was estimated at roughly twenty thousand dollars. Used replacement option: About $15,000 all-in - A used crate motor alternative was mentioned as slightly cheaper but still expensive. Apple Intelligence supported device note: M1 and up on Mac; iPhone 15 Pro requirement for on-device support - They discuss that Macs with M1 chips can run Apple Intelligence while iPhones require the 15 Pro class for local support. Xcode predictive completion RAM requirement: 16 GB unified memory - Xcode 16’s new code completion requires Apple silicon, macOS 15, and 16 GB RAM. VisionOS guest data reuse: 1 recent guest - VisionOS 2 can save the most recent guest’s eye and hand data for easier future setup.

Pivotal Quotes: "I have found a great use for the Vision Pro." — Host: Opening anecdote about recovering from a vasectomy and using Vision Pro while lying on the couch. "The engine is a catastrophic loss. We're going to need to replace it." — Volvo service representative (as relayed): The turning point in the extended car-damage story after the timing belt was shredded. "It's not 100%, but I think we've done everything that we know to do... I'm confident that it will be very high quality." — Tim Cook: Discussing Apple Intelligence reliability and the possibility of incorrect outputs.

Implications: Apple’s platforms are adding genuinely useful features, but AI and policy conflicts are exposing tradeoffs in RAM, defaults, privacy, and control. Expect more scrutiny from regulators, more hidden settings, and a bigger premium on hardware capacity and user trust.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Accidental Tech Podcast

View all episodes from Accidental Tech Podcast