The Ben Shapiro Show
The Ben Shapiro Show

Ep. 523 - The Worst Arguments For Gun Control

A shooting at a waffle house prompts some of the worst arguments for gun control ever, Americans can’t take a joke about prom dates, and Kanye 2020 launches. Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices Learn more about your ad choices. Visit podcastchoices.com/adchoices

Featured Speakers

The Ben Shapiro Show HostBen Shapiro Guest

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: Ben Shapiro centers the episode on the Waffle House shooting in Nashville, arguing the shooter’s known history and confiscated guns expose failures by law enforcement and family, while praising civilian hero James Shaw Jr. for disarming the attacker. He then critiques what he sees as absurd left-wing gun-control reactions, celebrity-driven politics, and cultural overreactions to jokes, ending with attacks on GQ’s anti-classic-literature list and criticism of Trump-centric political discourse.

Main Topics: Waffle House shooting and law-enforcement failure (Priority: 5/5): Shapiro recounts the Nashville Waffle House shooting, emphasizing that authorities had previously arrested the shooter, confiscated his firearms, and still ended up with him obtaining a weapon used in the attack. James Shaw Jr. as a civilian hero (Priority: 5/5): He frames Shaw as an American hero for charging the shooter, wresting away the AR-15, and stopping the attack, while arguing that armed defense would likely have lowered the risk even further. Critique of left-wing gun-control reactions (Priority: 5/5): He attacks reactions from David Axelrod, Emma Gonzalez, David Hogg, and Seth MacFarlane as logically flawed, especially claims that the Waffle House incident proves people do not need guns. Cultural overreaction to jokes and masculinity (Priority: 4/5): Shapiro discusses outrage over Jay Feely’s prom photo with a gun, arguing that a father jokingly defending his daughter should not be treated as toxic or threatening. Celebrity politics and the Trump effect (Priority: 4/5): He argues that celebrity opinions on politics are overrated, using Shania Twain and Kanye West as examples of public overreaction to famous people making political comments. Attack on GQ’s list of books not to read (Priority: 4/5): He ridicules GQ’s anti-canonical reading list as ideologically driven and anti-Western, defending works like Lonesome Dove, Huckleberry Finn, the Bible, Catch-22, and others.

Key Arguments: The Waffle House shooter was not an unknown or untracked threat; law enforcement and family members had prior contact and still enabled access to firearms. James Shaw Jr.’s actions show exceptional courage, but relying on hand-to-hand disarmament is a worse default than allowing law-abiding people to be armed. Left-wing claims that the shooting proves gun ownership is unnecessary are illogical and ignore the difference between an armed defender and an unarmed hero. Gun manufacturers should not be blamed for criminal misuse of a product when the product functions as designed; liability should hinge on defect or misuse, not moral guilt. Public outrage at Jay Feely’s joke reflects a cultural tendency to view guns as inherently evil and to treat normal protective masculinity as threatening. Celebrity political opinions are often overvalued, and the public’s obsession with Trump makes every celebrity statement into a political event. GQ’s anti-classic-literature list reflects shallow contemporary arrogance toward older works that shaped Western civilization.

Data Points: Killed in Waffle House shooting: 4 - Number of people killed in the Nashville Waffle House attack Injured in Waffle House shooting: at least 7 - Number of people injured in the Nashville Waffle House attack Previous firearm confiscation: 4 firearms - Police reportedly confiscated four guns from the shooter Large-scale post reach: 133,000 likes - Jay Feely’s prom photo tweet reportedly received this many likes Tweet engagement: 56,000 likes - David Hogg’s tweet about the Waffle House incident reportedly received this many likes Life insurance coverage gap: 71% need / 59% have - Shapiro cites a PolicyGenius statistic about Americans needing vs. having life insurance Coverage shortfall: 12% - The implied percentage of Americans procrastinating on life insurance Book length: about 240 pages - He describes Two Wings: Integrating Faith and Reason as a relatively short read

Pivotal Quotes: "That dude's an American hero." — Ben Shapiro: His praise of James Shaw Jr. after recounting how Shaw disarmed the shooter "With yet another mass shooting today, let us give full recognition to Colt, the manufacturer of the AR semi-automatic rifle used in this massacre, for designing such an efficient weapon." — David Axelrod: Tweet Shapiro cites as an example of what he считает a flawed gun-control argument "Looks like you don't need to arm a teacher or a resource officer to stop a shooting." — Emma Gonzalez: Tweet Shapiro uses to illustrate what he views as a misleading conclusion from the Waffle House attack

Implications: Listeners are pushed toward skepticism of simplistic gun-control narratives, greater appreciation for civilian courage and defensive preparedness, and more caution about celebrity-driven political judgment and culture-war outrage.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About The Ben Shapiro Show

Tired of the lies? Tired of the spin? Are you ready to hear the hard-hitting truth in comprehensive, conservative, principled fashion? The Ben Shapiro Show brings you all the news you need to know in the most fast moving daily program in America. Ben brutally breaks down the culture and never gives an inch! Monday thru Friday.

View all episodes from The Ben Shapiro Show