Plain English with Derek Thompson
Plain English with Derek Thompson

Harsh Truths About 2024 and the Future of the U.S. Economy

On today's episode: the state of American politics and the future of America's economy. Derek discusses a media myth in the aftermath of the failed Trump assassination attempt and reviews three basic truths about Joe Biden's doomed presidential bid. Then, Chicago Fed president Austan

Featured Speakers

Derek Thompson GuestAustin Goolsbee Guest

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode opens with a meta-update on podcast scheduling and a lengthy political commentary arguing that the 2024 election is chaotic but not fundamentally altered by recent shocks. The second half is an interview with Chicago Fed President Austin Goolsbee, who explains the Fed’s dual mandate, defends the “golden path” disinflation, warns about over-tightening as labor cools, and says tariffs would raise prices but not necessarily trigger persistent inflation unless retaliation escalates.

Main Topics: Podcast programming and format update (Priority: 2/5): The host previews expanded House of the Dragon coverage across multiple shows and platforms, then explains a new approach to mixing politics with the podcast: occasional long political opens paired with interviews on other topics. 2024 election volatility and media overreaction (Priority: 5/5): The host surveys a week of dramatic political news—Trump assassination attempt, Vance VP pick, documents-case dismissal, Biden pressure to withdraw, Biden COVID—and argues that pundits are overstating how much any one event changes the race. Biden’s candidacy problem (Priority: 5/5): A central argument is that Biden is losing ground because voters, including many in his party, think he is too old and because no communications strategy can solve the underlying issue of visible decline. Failed assassination attempt and historical uncertainty (Priority: 4/5): The host cites research suggesting failed assassination attempts in democracies often have little lasting effect, insisting nobody can know yet what the Trump attack means for the election or broader political violence. Federal Reserve mechanics and Goolsbee’s role (Priority: 4/5): Goolsbee explains what a regional Fed president does, how the FOMC operates, and how the Chicago Fed combines policymaking, supervision, and community engagement. Inflation, rates, and the 'golden path' (Priority: 5/5): Goolsbee argues the U.S. achieved unusually fast disinflation without a recession, thanks to restored supply chains, Fed credibility, and an economy that proved less rate-sensitive than expected. Tariffs, housing, and supply-side effects (Priority: 4/5): The interview closes on the limits of monetary policy, the housing lock-in effect from high mortgage rates, and the claim that broad tariffs would lift prices one time but could become more inflationary if they provoke retaliation.

Key Arguments: The host argues the current news cycle is so crowded that even shocking events may have limited durable political impact; polls still show Trump narrowly/moderately ahead. Biden’s core problem is not Democratic branding but his personal age and visible communication decline, which no campaign tactics can fully fix. Replacing Biden is risky, but the current path may be worse; high-risk alternatives become more rational when the baseline situation is deteriorating. Historical research suggests failed assassination attempts in democracies often produce little lasting change, unlike in authoritarian systems. Goolsbee says the Fed’s job is strictly to stabilize prices and maximize employment, not to anticipate election outcomes or fiscal policy. The Fed successfully reduced inflation sharply in 2023 without a major recession, supporting the idea of an unusually favorable disinflation path. Keeping rates high while inflation falls is effectively tightening in real terms, so the Fed must watch for labor-market softening and recession signals. High mortgage rates suppress housing transactions and some construction, but this is largely a temporary lock-in effect rather than proof that rate hikes raise inflation. Tariffs generally raise prices one time; they become more inflationary only if retaliation triggers a broader tariff spiral.

Data Points: Failed assassination attempts studied: 298 attempts - Jones and Olken’s dataset on world leaders, 1897-2004 Fatal outcomes in assassination attempts: 59 deaths - Of the 298 attempts studied, only 59 resulted in leader deaths Inflation rate decline: Largest one-year drop in recorded economic history (approx.) - Goolsbee describes 2023 disinflation as among the biggest in history without a major recession Federal funds rate: 5.25% to 5.5% - Rate level held for about a year before expected cut discussions Core PCE inflation: Over 4% to trending toward 2% - Used to illustrate why the stance of policy may now be more restrictive than before Unemployment rate: 4.1% - Host cites current labor market conditions before asking about cooling Unemployment change: Up 0.5 percentage point over several months - Goolsbee notes this gradual rise is unusual historically Mortgage rate example: 4% mortgage vs. 8.5% mortgage - Illustrates housing lock-in and why existing-home supply is constrained Fed rate increase: 550 basis points - Describes the cumulative tightening cycle over a short period Tariff range discussed: 10% to 50% - Hypothetical across-the-board tariffs proposed in the election context Chicago Fed vault cash: $25 billion - Goolsbee describes the Fed’s operational scale and responsibilities

Pivotal Quotes: "Nobody knows. Nobody knows what it means for the November election or for the future of political violence." — Derek Thompson: On the failed assassination attempt of Donald Trump and the danger of pundits overclaiming certainty "The facts of the case are these, and they are undisputed." — Derek Thompson: Transition into the argument that Biden’s age and communications problems are politically fatal "I was calling it the Golden Path." — Austin Goolsbee: Explaining the unusually successful disinflation of 2023 without a recession

Implications: Listeners should expect continued political volatility but not assume every headline changes the race. Economically, the episode signals that the Fed may soon ease rates, while high rates still distort housing and tariffs would likely lift consumer prices.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Plain English with Derek Thompson

View all episodes from Plain English with Derek Thompson