Episode Summary
Executive Summary: Brent Johnson discusses the US dollar's resilience and his Dollar Milkshake Theory, arguing that the dollar will strengthen during a global debt crisis. He presents a balanced view on inflation vs. deflation, suggesting deflation is a near-term risk due to lack of bank lending and falling wages. He advises a diversified portfolio avoiding all-in bets, sees potential in soft commodities on pullbacks, and expects gold to trade sideways with possible dips to $1,600.
Main Topics: US Dollar Outlook and Dollar Milkshake Theory (Priority: 5/5): Brent argues the dollar is not collapsing due to relative fiat currency dynamics and expects it to strengthen during a global debt crisis, sucking up liquidity. Inflation vs. Deflation Debate (Priority: 5/5): Brent sees current inflation as largely transitory, driven by supply chain disruptions, and believes deflation is the bigger near-term risk due to low bank lending and falling wages. Gold and Silver Analysis (Priority: 4/5): Brent expects gold to trade sideways to lower, potentially testing $1,600, and sees silver possibly going lower before a sustained rally. Equities and Portfolio Construction (Priority: 4/5): Brent expects a pullback in equities (15-20%) but sees secular upside. He advocates for a diversified portfolio and avoiding all-in strategies. Commodities, Especially Soft Commodities (Priority: 4/5): Brent and Patrick are cautious on industrial commodities near highs but bullish on soft commodities (coffee, soybeans) on pullbacks due to sustained food demand. Bitcoin and Cryptocurrency Risks (Priority: 3/5): Brent is cautious on Bitcoin short-term due to regulatory pressures and the risk of Tether being exposed as a fraud. He sees digital assets here to stay.
Key Arguments: The US dollar is not collapsing; it is higher than in 2008 despite massive QE, because all major central banks are debasing their currencies similarly, making it a relative game. Sustained inflation requires bank lending and rising wages, which are currently absent. Commercial and industrial loans have fallen, and wage growth has reverted to trend. The bond market (10-year yield below 1.2%) is not signaling runaway inflation, indicating the market expects disinflation/deflation. A diversified portfolio (equities, gold, real estate, bonds) is optimal for uncertainty. Avoid all-in bets; wait for clear opportunities before being aggressive. Soft commodities offer asymmetric upside on pullbacks due to inelastic food demand and potential supply disruptions from climate/pests. Bitcoin faces near-term headwinds from regulation and Tether risk. It has a portfolio role but should not replace gold entirely.
Data Points: US Dollar Index level: 92-93 - Dollar remains at similar level to a year ago despite $1.4 trillion printing, contested elections, and social unrest. 10-Year Treasury Yield: ~1.2% - Bond yields broke below support from 2012, indicating bond market doubts about sustained inflation. Gold Price: ~$1,800 - Gold is down ~10% from August 2020 highs (~$2,100) and down ~5-6% year-to-date. Brent sees potential dip to $1,600. Lumber Price Decline: ~66% decline from peak - Lumber fell from over $1,500 to around $500, showing mean reversion in a previously parabolic market. Commercial and Industrial Loans: Declining nearly every month - Loans fell after PPP programs ended, indicating banks are not lending, which is needed for sustained inflation. Velocity of Money: All-time lows - Low velocity suggests money is not circulating rapidly, contradicting runaway inflation narratives. Bitcoin Price: ~$38,000 - Bitcoin pulled back from $65,000 high; Brent sold most holdings above $28k and expects further downside.
Pivotal Quotes: "I have been labeled a deflationist... I would say that I feel like I could flip to the other side pretty quickly if I see a few things happen." — Brent Johnson: Explaining his balanced view on inflation vs. deflation and openness to changing his stance based on data. "When I look at what [banks] are doing, they're buying bonds, they're not making loans. So I struggle to see without a few things changing... the sustained inflation that so many are convinced is here." — Brent Johnson: Highlighting the lack of bank lending as evidence that inflation may not be persistent. "I think the dollar will, for many reasons, be the last man standing. And I think as that happens, the dollar will suck up the global liquidity, hence the dollar milkshake." — Brent Johnson: Explaining the Dollar Milkshake Theory—that the dollar will strengthen during a global debt crisis.
Implications: Listeners should prepare for potential deflationary risks, avoid overconcentration in any single asset class, and watch for pullbacks in soft commodities as opportunities. The dollar may strengthen in a crisis, hurting commodity prices near-term, but secular bull trends in commodities remain intact.
About Macro Voices
Weekly market commentary by Hedge Fund Manager Erik Townsend and interviews with the brightest minds in the world of finance and macroeconomics. Made possible by funding from Fourth Turning Capital Management, LLC