Accidental Tech Podcast
Accidental Tech Podcast

626: No Longer ery Good

* Follow-up: * Flighty has other perks (via Stephen Klinck) * First reports of Invites use in the wild (via Jim Weinert) * You can use a cable with Sidecar (via Matt West) * Why not use a Wi-Fi hotspot for “cellar Macs”? * Tailgate Tub * Why not AirPlay to Sonos speakers? (via Ryan Powers) * DeepSee

Featured Speakers

Marco Arment, Casey Liss, John Siracusa Host

Topics Discussed

Episode Summary

Executive Summary: The episode covers Apple ecosystem frustrations and updates: failing MacBook Air keyboards, the newly announced migration of purchases between Apple IDs, ongoing complaints about tethering and Screen Time reliability, Sonos/AirPlay use cases, and Apple’s UK encryption backdoor controversy. It also discusses Switch 2 Joy-Con mouse patents, Apple’s emotive robotics research, and several listener follow-ups on tech workflows and file-system behavior.

Main Topics: MacBook Air wear, upgrade temptation, and tethering pain: Marco describes keyboard failures on an M2 MacBook Air, the annoyance of unreliable iPhone tethering on ferries/trains, and reasons he might upgrade if Apple ships a brighter display or nanotexture option. Apple account purchase migration and its limitations: The hosts unpack Apple’s new feature to migrate purchases between Apple accounts, noting that it is not a true account merge and carries many restrictions, bugs, and region limits. Cellular Macs vs hotspots for mobility: The hosts argue that built-in cellular would solve real workflow problems better than a separate hotspot device, which adds charging, management, and cost overhead. Sonos app vs AirPlay use philosophies: They debate whether the Sonos app is necessary in the AirPlay 2 era, contrasting Marc​o’s preference for direct AirPlay/TV integration with Casey’s desire to keep house music management inside the Sonos app. Screen Time unreliability and Apple ecosystem trust: Listener feedback reinforces that Screen Time reports are often absurd or unusable, supporting the hosts’ long-running criticism that the feature is effectively unreliable. Apple in the UK: encrypted iCloud backdoor concerns: The hosts react strongly to reports that the UK wants global access to encrypted iCloud backups, arguing that the demand is technically and politically dangerous and likely untenable. Apple research on emotive robot motion: Apple’s robotics research video is discussed as evidence of a future moving-screen/home-device direction, but the hosts doubt Apple can ship expressive motion without first fixing baseline reliability.

Key Arguments: Built-in cellular on a Mac would solve recurring tethering failures better than hotspots or phone tethering, which are unreliable and cumbersome in real-world travel use. Apple’s purchase migration feature is useful but not a full Apple ID merge; it transfers purchases only and has many caveats that make it risky to use immediately. Screen Time’s numbers are so inconsistent that they may be close to meaningless for tracking or parental controls. AirPlay is fine for many users, but the Sonos app remains useful for centralized control of speakers, volume, and home audio separation. A government-mandated backdoor to encrypted cloud backups is effectively a backdoor for everyone, not just criminals; it weakens security broadly and invites abuse. Apple’s expressive robot research may be visually appealing, but it won’t matter unless the device reliably does the task people asked for. For file deduplication/reclaiming, data identity matters more than metadata; metadata should be preserved as much as possible, but some fields are controlled by the filesystem or SIP and cannot be guaranteed.

Data Points: Apple ID migration wait time: 25 years - John characterizes the new Apple purchase-migration feature as something users have waited decades for. Apple account migration region exclusions: EU, United Kingdom, India - The feature is not available in these regions. Test Flight access loss: all enrollments lost - Migrating purchases removes TestFlight access from the secondary account. Screen Time absurd daily average: 2,395 hours and 49 minutes - A listener screenshot showed an obviously impossible Screen Time number. Hotspot monthly cost: $50/month - Marco’s AT&T hotspot plan was cited as expensive relative to built-in cellular. Terminal refresh interval: up to every 15 minutes - The battery-saving terminal display updates at a limited cadence to preserve battery life. Terminal battery estimate: about 6 months - The device was quoted as lasting months between charges under conservative refresh settings. Wi-Fi hotspot checkouts: 3–4 weeks - A library loaner hotspot can be checked out for several weeks at no cost. Network speeds discussed: 2.5 gig / 10 gig - The restaurant network and home networking discussion centers on faster-than-gigabit links. Dante audio over network: multiple channels, likely 4–6 - Marco plans to route restaurant audio over Dante with substantial network headroom.

Pivotal Quotes: "I want a cellular Mac. That's what I want." — Marco: He explains that built-in cellular would eliminate the tethering problems he experiences on ferries and trains. "If you just complain about something every single day, eventually something happens to address the thing you were complaining about." — John: He jokingly downplays credit for Apple’s new Apple ID purchase-migration feature. "This misguided attempt at tackling crime and terrorism will not make the UK safer, but it will erode the fundamental rights and civil liberties of the entire population." — Big Brother Watch quoted in the episode: The hosts discuss the UK order demanding access to encrypted iCloud backups.

Implications: Listeners get a clear picture of where Apple is improving and where it still frustrates power users. The episode suggests major privacy and ecosystem battles are ahead, while also showing practical workflows where hardware and software reliability matter more than feature hype.

🔓 Sign Up for Unlimited Episode Search

About Accidental Tech Podcast

View all episodes from Accidental Tech Podcast